TPLINK OMADA setup with PFSense? 2 ISPs, single mesh design. Got any suggestions?
TPLINK OMADA setup with PFSense? 2 ISPs, single mesh design. Got any suggestions?
You're looking for a compact decoder that works independently with its own power supply. There are models designed to be self-contained, using external power adapters and requiring only a shelf for mounting. For connecting two ISPs, you'll need a solution that splits traffic or enables failover without drilling holes in walls. Options include dedicated modems with built-in power management and external power supplies, as well as network devices that support traffic balancing and automatic switching.
I believed I was being precise, but the second idea belongs to another stage of the project where we need just one Wi-Fi network name. Got any suggestions?
It doesn’t seem to be available in that form. Also, the setup works best when linking both ISPs to the same network.
They don’t know what the most affordable box offers. Regarding security tools, PFSense, OPNsense, and others typically don’t have this feature. If the cheapest dual WAN box isn’t inexpensive, upgrading an old computer to act as a router might be a better option. Also, for optimal PFSense performance, avoid using a core 2 duo system.
The Synology model you referred to is more expensive than a basic outdated 12th generation Pentium Celeron setup. Does the Ubiquiti Cloud Key Gen 2 or Dream Router work with it? You’re looking for a budget PC instead of a network switch, so you can save money.
The Dream Machine router costs $299 USD while I paid $200 for the Synology model. The product page doesn’t display dual WAN options. The cloud key isn’t for routing—it’s meant to manage Ubquiti devices. Dual WAN isn’t a standard feature since most users don’t have multiple internet connections. Keep in mind that with PF-Sense you’ll still need a wireless AP for Wi-Fi and a network switch, as those functions are weak there. I’d also consider watching YouTube setup guides, since this setup won’t be as straightforward as buying a ready-made router. I’m aware Amazon and Ali Express have small devices built for this kind of use, though the exact price isn’t clear.
Review the Deco guide thoroughly. It details how configurations change when switching from router mode to AP mode, highlighting which features remain or disappear. The process depends on your hardware and NIC compatibility with the firewall OS. You need a minimum of three assignable Ethernet ports—one for each WAN connection and one for switching output. Both Ubiquiti EdgeRouter-X and USG support dual-WAN with load balancing or failover capabilities. UDM-Pro/SE can handle these too, though it’s better suited if you’re already using UniFi gear. TP-Link and D-Link models with VPN routers also offer dual-WAN, but they may be pricier than the ER-X or USG options. They provide multi-gig ports. I’m not sure pfSense will work well on a Core 2 Duo, but running it continuously could offset any savings from building your own setup. Firewall appliances are designed to balance performance and energy use. The Netgate 1100 supports pfSense and uses less power.