F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Looking for guidance on choosing a CPU for video editing?

Looking for guidance on choosing a CPU for video editing?

Looking for guidance on choosing a CPU for video editing?

Pages (2): Previous 1 2
J
Jeeplet
Junior Member
17
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#11
C-Tier suits a budget GPU such as the 5060 Ti. When conditions are similar, it performs adequately. However, chip quality plays a bigger role and WD allocates less to the SN5000 in this regard. Both provide comparable warranties, and the NV3 has a longer rated lifespan. Based on my experience, they match in customer service. Personally, I’d prefer AM4 over AM5 if it means a better GPU instead of a subpar one. Upgrading GPUs is costly, so it’s smarter to invest in current capabilities rather than chasing future resolutions. A $100 investment in a case feels excessive for this price point... it’s way too much. Regarding airflow, it meets the minimum standards for budget components. The GPU handles the task, not the CPU, so video editing performance isn’t a major concern.
J
Jeeplet
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #11

C-Tier suits a budget GPU such as the 5060 Ti. When conditions are similar, it performs adequately. However, chip quality plays a bigger role and WD allocates less to the SN5000 in this regard. Both provide comparable warranties, and the NV3 has a longer rated lifespan. Based on my experience, they match in customer service. Personally, I’d prefer AM4 over AM5 if it means a better GPU instead of a subpar one. Upgrading GPUs is costly, so it’s smarter to invest in current capabilities rather than chasing future resolutions. A $100 investment in a case feels excessive for this price point... it’s way too much. Regarding airflow, it meets the minimum standards for budget components. The GPU handles the task, not the CPU, so video editing performance isn’t a major concern.

J
Jerryx01
Posting Freak
870
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#12
AMD CPUs don't have a good onboard video encoder/decoder which matters for most video editing programs because that's the accelerator they use for scrubbing video. If the CPU is powerful enough, software mode will be fine, but in this case he really needs Intel. I think the CPU is fine, but the RAM should be 64GB if he can squeeze in an extra $100. The 5060 is good for the price. I don't think VRAM matters and the CUDA computing capability is similar to high end cards from 3 generations earlier so it would do a good job with video encoding. I don't know anything about effects because I don't do that kind of video editing.
J
Jerryx01
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #12

AMD CPUs don't have a good onboard video encoder/decoder which matters for most video editing programs because that's the accelerator they use for scrubbing video. If the CPU is powerful enough, software mode will be fine, but in this case he really needs Intel. I think the CPU is fine, but the RAM should be 64GB if he can squeeze in an extra $100. The 5060 is good for the price. I don't think VRAM matters and the CUDA computing capability is similar to high end cards from 3 generations earlier so it would do a good job with video encoding. I don't know anything about effects because I don't do that kind of video editing.

S
Sloth_Gaming
Member
137
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#13
I don’t have any background in setting up a PC for video editing, but I understand why Intel was the top pick—it offers exclusive hardware support for HEVC. With the 50 series handling h.264 and h.265, it seems reasonable to stick with Intel for the CPU unless AMD offers a better balance now. The graph you mentioned from Puget gives useful insights for this decision.
S
Sloth_Gaming
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #13

I don’t have any background in setting up a PC for video editing, but I understand why Intel was the top pick—it offers exclusive hardware support for HEVC. With the 50 series handling h.264 and h.265, it seems reasonable to stick with Intel for the CPU unless AMD offers a better balance now. The graph you mentioned from Puget gives useful insights for this decision.

K
KiritoG
Junior Member
33
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#14
With a dedicated GPU, it can handle encoding and decoding, so the CPU doesn't have to manage many codecs.
K
KiritoG
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #14

With a dedicated GPU, it can handle encoding and decoding, so the CPU doesn't have to manage many codecs.

J
jameel1702
Member
68
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#15
I checked the specifications and noticed the differences between the drives. The WD Blue SN5000 1 TB offers 600 TBW, while the NV3 1 TB provides 320 TBW. That’s a significant gap. I double-checked the datasheets to confirm the numbers.
J
jameel1702
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #15

I checked the specifications and noticed the differences between the drives. The WD Blue SN5000 1 TB offers 600 TBW, while the NV3 1 TB provides 320 TBW. That’s a significant gap. I double-checked the datasheets to confirm the numbers.

T
tigg1000
Member
69
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#16
Can't locate the referenced data for my quoted figure (300 TBW). The numbers cited there appear inaccurate. Usually, doubling capacity means doubling endurance since there are twice as many cells. Yet every source I’ve found also mentions 600. Fascinating.
T
tigg1000
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #16

Can't locate the referenced data for my quoted figure (300 TBW). The numbers cited there appear inaccurate. Usually, doubling capacity means doubling endurance since there are twice as many cells. Yet every source I’ve found also mentions 600. Fascinating.

D
DannyFrenzyy
Junior Member
10
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#17
Confirm if this applies to scrubbing in Davinci. It involves navigating the timeline without exporting and rendering video live.
D
DannyFrenzyy
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #17

Confirm if this applies to scrubbing in Davinci. It involves navigating the timeline without exporting and rendering video live.

N
Nero12321
Posting Freak
858
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#18
It seems rendering happens on the GPU when scrubbing starts, provided one is available. The CPU's role is limited to passing data to the GPU, nothing further required. I'm still not entirely confident about this.
N
Nero12321
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #18

It seems rendering happens on the GPU when scrubbing starts, provided one is available. The CPU's role is limited to passing data to the GPU, nothing further required. I'm still not entirely confident about this.

T
TiTansio11
Member
189
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM
#19
Based on my limited grasp, it seems scrubbing is typically handled by QuickSync or the encoding/decoding hardware in the iGPU. This setup supports various H.265 video codecs with different bit depths and chroma sampling. The GPU manages VFX processing in real time, leaving the mainframe to handle decoding/encoding. My interest lies in how video editors would adapt their processes if a dedicated GPU could replace QuickSync. Would professionals stick with Intel or move toward AMD?
T
TiTansio11
11-22-2018, 08:49 AM #19

Based on my limited grasp, it seems scrubbing is typically handled by QuickSync or the encoding/decoding hardware in the iGPU. This setup supports various H.265 video codecs with different bit depths and chroma sampling. The GPU manages VFX processing in real time, leaving the mainframe to handle decoding/encoding. My interest lies in how video editors would adapt their processes if a dedicated GPU could replace QuickSync. Would professionals stick with Intel or move toward AMD?

Pages (2): Previous 1 2