F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Innovative method for cooling that eliminates the need for thermal paste.

Innovative method for cooling that eliminates the need for thermal paste.

Innovative method for cooling that eliminates the need for thermal paste.

S
Sqwalish
Member
155
10-01-2023, 07:59 PM
#1
Considered an alternative approach instead of thermal paste. Instead of using paste, we could install slots on both the CPU IHS and Cooler Pad, then align them before mounting the CPU in the motherboard socket. This would eliminate any air gap between the IHS and Cooler Pad, potentially improving heat transfer. Not sure if anyone has tried this before. I’d appreciate it if Linus experiments with it and compares the outcomes to standard coolers with paste.
S
Sqwalish
10-01-2023, 07:59 PM #1

Considered an alternative approach instead of thermal paste. Instead of using paste, we could install slots on both the CPU IHS and Cooler Pad, then align them before mounting the CPU in the motherboard socket. This would eliminate any air gap between the IHS and Cooler Pad, potentially improving heat transfer. Not sure if anyone has tried this before. I’d appreciate it if Linus experiments with it and compares the outcomes to standard coolers with paste.

O
OkuyasuTBH
Junior Member
17
10-07-2023, 09:08 AM
#2
There would remain some inconsistencies because the current method isn't perfectly accurate enough, creating a minor difference. It's not ideal for thermal performance.
O
OkuyasuTBH
10-07-2023, 09:08 AM #2

There would remain some inconsistencies because the current method isn't perfectly accurate enough, creating a minor difference. It's not ideal for thermal performance.

R
Ryan_0402
Junior Member
2
10-14-2023, 03:32 PM
#3
No, a cooling pad and the Carbonaut serve different purposes. A cooling pad is typically used for comfort during physical activity, while the Carbonaut is a device designed to purify air by removing odors and pollutants.
R
Ryan_0402
10-14-2023, 03:32 PM #3

No, a cooling pad and the Carbonaut serve different purposes. A cooling pad is typically used for comfort during physical activity, while the Carbonaut is a device designed to purify air by removing odors and pollutants.

V
Viplo
Member
67
10-20-2023, 08:10 PM
#4
Cold Plate
V
Viplo
10-20-2023, 08:10 PM #4

Cold Plate

R
RavenRavine
Member
197
11-03-2023, 12:07 AM
#5
I believe OP is envisioning a setup where the cooler's cold plate and the IHS stack function like Lego pieces. As mentioned in my reply to the double comment, achieving this demands an extremely accurate manufacturing method with tight tolerances. We must use thermal paste since producers can't guarantee both components are perfectly flat. The paste bridges the tiny gaps between them. This situation is similar here—unless the parts align flawlessly at a microscopic scale, you'll still encounter gaps needing filling. Now your production process becomes more intricate, costly, and susceptible to compatibility problems between the parts.
R
RavenRavine
11-03-2023, 12:07 AM #5

I believe OP is envisioning a setup where the cooler's cold plate and the IHS stack function like Lego pieces. As mentioned in my reply to the double comment, achieving this demands an extremely accurate manufacturing method with tight tolerances. We must use thermal paste since producers can't guarantee both components are perfectly flat. The paste bridges the tiny gaps between them. This situation is similar here—unless the parts align flawlessly at a microscopic scale, you'll still encounter gaps needing filling. Now your production process becomes more intricate, costly, and susceptible to compatibility problems between the parts.

X
xFqtal_
Senior Member
670
11-03-2023, 01:12 AM
#6
The requirement for minimal tolerance is confirmed, though modern machining methods like laser cutting make it feasible.
X
xFqtal_
11-03-2023, 01:12 AM #6

The requirement for minimal tolerance is confirmed, though modern machining methods like laser cutting make it feasible.

W
WikiliZ
Member
196
11-09-2023, 04:00 AM
#7
The displayed pattern also resembles a dovetail style, similar to designs found on lathes.
W
WikiliZ
11-09-2023, 04:00 AM #7

The displayed pattern also resembles a dovetail style, similar to designs found on lathes.

S
SabrinaOG
Junior Member
12
11-10-2023, 06:59 AM
#8
You're referring to the challenges of installation. The process demands careful handling due to potential friction and wear from any tilt. Tight tolerances can make it difficult for users to assemble properly, requiring a gap that must be filled with thermal paste again. Applying and removing it becomes more complex. Having two flat surfaces is simpler to produce and manage, likely offering better cooling performance.
S
SabrinaOG
11-10-2023, 06:59 AM #8

You're referring to the challenges of installation. The process demands careful handling due to potential friction and wear from any tilt. Tight tolerances can make it difficult for users to assemble properly, requiring a gap that must be filled with thermal paste again. Applying and removing it becomes more complex. Having two flat surfaces is simpler to produce and manage, likely offering better cooling performance.

S
Shadow_foxx
Junior Member
6
11-19-2023, 11:16 AM
#9
I understand OP didn't intend it, but just reading it made me think they might have created cooling pads on the spot! In my opinion, this isn't a good choice for everyday use since it's unclear how to set it up and whether any real benefits exist. It would be smarter to focus on creating more energy-efficient components, which is already happening with longer-term improvements. I own two Ryzen processors in the past half-year; while I've often felt a bit let down by their performance (I seem to prefer picking the wrong model), they’ve always been decent. The 3600 really stands out compared to the 2200G—it can get warm during tests even without the graphics card, but it stays manageable under typical use. PS: I also thought about a solution—if cooling efficiency is an issue, maybe integrate the CPU, cooler, and motherboard together from the start. That would be the most effective approach, though it depends on cost and whether enough research is needed. Plus, people might not like the idea of being told they can't upgrade their CPU!
S
Shadow_foxx
11-19-2023, 11:16 AM #9

I understand OP didn't intend it, but just reading it made me think they might have created cooling pads on the spot! In my opinion, this isn't a good choice for everyday use since it's unclear how to set it up and whether any real benefits exist. It would be smarter to focus on creating more energy-efficient components, which is already happening with longer-term improvements. I own two Ryzen processors in the past half-year; while I've often felt a bit let down by their performance (I seem to prefer picking the wrong model), they’ve always been decent. The 3600 really stands out compared to the 2200G—it can get warm during tests even without the graphics card, but it stays manageable under typical use. PS: I also thought about a solution—if cooling efficiency is an issue, maybe integrate the CPU, cooler, and motherboard together from the start. That would be the most effective approach, though it depends on cost and whether enough research is needed. Plus, people might not like the idea of being told they can't upgrade their CPU!

K
Kad3n4709
Junior Member
47
11-19-2023, 08:12 PM
#10
Absolutely, I get it now. Thanks for the clarity—this really helps me see things more clearly. Looking forward to our next chat with fresh ideas!
K
Kad3n4709
11-19-2023, 08:12 PM #10

Absolutely, I get it now. Thanks for the clarity—this really helps me see things more clearly. Looking forward to our next chat with fresh ideas!