F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Experience issues when the device is hit.

Experience issues when the device is hit.

Experience issues when the device is hit.

J
Jarks24
Junior Member
37
01-21-2020, 01:24 PM
#1
Hi everyone, I've been facing this problem for nearly a year now. I don't have extra funds or spare components, which has made it tough to pinpoint the cause. Usually, when my computer gets a shock, it crashes—either through a BSOD or by freezing completely before restarting. Changing the cables hasn't helped much, but reinserting my RAM sometimes temporarily solved it (though it usually returns after a few days). The BSOD messages often say something like "Attempted write to read-only memory," leading me to think the RAM might be faulty. Recently, I managed to acquire replacement parts, but even then, the initial days felt like I’d found the right fix. However, shaking up my PC’s power supply just now triggered the error and crash again. Without the option to buy or borrow parts, and with my job relying heavily on computer availability, I’m struggling to figure out exactly what’s going wrong and how to resolve it. Any insights or advice from others would be greatly appreciated.

Details:
- Model: MSI MAG X570 TOMAHAWK WIFI CPU
- GPU: ASUS RTX 3070
- RAM: 2x16 GB G.Skill Ripjaws V 3600
- PSU: Super Flower Leadex Platinum 850
- Boot Drive: WD Black SN_850 500GB SSD
- HDD: Toshiba X300 7200RPM 4TB
- OS: Windows 10
J
Jarks24
01-21-2020, 01:24 PM #1

Hi everyone, I've been facing this problem for nearly a year now. I don't have extra funds or spare components, which has made it tough to pinpoint the cause. Usually, when my computer gets a shock, it crashes—either through a BSOD or by freezing completely before restarting. Changing the cables hasn't helped much, but reinserting my RAM sometimes temporarily solved it (though it usually returns after a few days). The BSOD messages often say something like "Attempted write to read-only memory," leading me to think the RAM might be faulty. Recently, I managed to acquire replacement parts, but even then, the initial days felt like I’d found the right fix. However, shaking up my PC’s power supply just now triggered the error and crash again. Without the option to buy or borrow parts, and with my job relying heavily on computer availability, I’m struggling to figure out exactly what’s going wrong and how to resolve it. Any insights or advice from others would be greatly appreciated.

Details:
- Model: MSI MAG X570 TOMAHAWK WIFI CPU
- GPU: ASUS RTX 3070
- RAM: 2x16 GB G.Skill Ripjaws V 3600
- PSU: Super Flower Leadex Platinum 850
- Boot Drive: WD Black SN_850 500GB SSD
- HDD: Toshiba X300 7200RPM 4TB
- OS: Windows 10

S
sashahyd
Junior Member
11
02-03-2020, 02:26 PM
#2
Everything appears normal. The hard drive would damage itself if it attempted to write while the platter wasn’t accessible, which is why it powers off.
S
sashahyd
02-03-2020, 02:26 PM #2

Everything appears normal. The hard drive would damage itself if it attempted to write while the platter wasn’t accessible, which is why it powers off.

D
Deeon
Member
61
02-04-2020, 07:57 AM
#3
I'm not entirely convinced by this—my concern isn't about it occurring during heavy use. Instead, I think a quick rise from my chair creates a minor vibration that travels through the floor, impacts the table legs, and triggers the PC to restart. This isn't my first experience with an HDD-based setup, and I haven't encountered anything like this before. For the past year or so, it hasn't happened, and I don't regularly store anything on the drive except for photos, videos, or old files. Still, if you believe this is the problem, I could test running without connecting the drive.
D
Deeon
02-04-2020, 07:57 AM #3

I'm not entirely convinced by this—my concern isn't about it occurring during heavy use. Instead, I think a quick rise from my chair creates a minor vibration that travels through the floor, impacts the table legs, and triggers the PC to restart. This isn't my first experience with an HDD-based setup, and I haven't encountered anything like this before. For the past year or so, it hasn't happened, and I don't regularly store anything on the drive except for photos, videos, or old files. Still, if you believe this is the problem, I could test running without connecting the drive.

S
starwarsoliv
Junior Member
9
02-05-2020, 03:11 AM
#4
HDDs slowing down don't lead to memory issues. Also, 3.5" drives typically lack accelerometers unlike 2.5" models. If you skip DOCP/XMP settings, what might occur?
S
starwarsoliv
02-05-2020, 03:11 AM #4

HDDs slowing down don't lead to memory issues. Also, 3.5" drives typically lack accelerometers unlike 2.5" models. If you skip DOCP/XMP settings, what might occur?

B
Brek_
Member
249
02-05-2020, 12:00 PM
#5
I disabled XMP on my original setup, though I didn't observe a clear change. Possibly it marginally reduced crash frequency, but I'm unsure if that's real or just optimism. Ultimately, it wasn't a solution.
B
Brek_
02-05-2020, 12:00 PM #5

I disabled XMP on my original setup, though I didn't observe a clear change. Possibly it marginally reduced crash frequency, but I'm unsure if that's real or just optimism. Ultimately, it wasn't a solution.

X
xXRAXERXx
Posting Freak
817
02-05-2020, 05:24 PM
#6
It seems quite risky in my view. You might want to attempt repositioning the CPU. Look for bent pins or excessive tightness. What concerns me is the possibility of losing power. I recommend taking everything apart and reassembling it from the case first—just on top of the motherboard. Then test by gently tapping your desk or applying a light percussive force to the motherboard. You could also test with a single RAM stick during the process.
X
xXRAXERXx
02-05-2020, 05:24 PM #6

It seems quite risky in my view. You might want to attempt repositioning the CPU. Look for bent pins or excessive tightness. What concerns me is the possibility of losing power. I recommend taking everything apart and reassembling it from the case first—just on top of the motherboard. Then test by gently tapping your desk or applying a light percussive force to the motherboard. You could also test with a single RAM stick during the process.

A
152
02-05-2020, 10:24 PM
#7
Issue with PCI-E port or RAM connections.
A
AgentDarkJewel
02-05-2020, 10:24 PM #7

Issue with PCI-E port or RAM connections.

P
paperclip364
Member
174
02-19-2020, 08:53 PM
#8
That's unfortunate if true - don't have easy access to another motherboard, and RMAing mine seems like it could take a fair bit of time.
P
paperclip364
02-19-2020, 08:53 PM #8

That's unfortunate if true - don't have easy access to another motherboard, and RMAing mine seems like it could take a fair bit of time.

F
freezy2004
Junior Member
23
02-20-2020, 02:10 AM
#9
Removed all components and put them back together again. I'll let you know if the problem comes back. Assuming everything is secure, I'm confident it's just a loose part that's been fixed.
F
freezy2004
02-20-2020, 02:10 AM #9

Removed all components and put them back together again. I'll let you know if the problem comes back. Assuming everything is secure, I'm confident it's just a loose part that's been fixed.

I
Infamousy
Member
207
02-21-2020, 07:13 PM
#10
Problem has been reported
I
Infamousy
02-21-2020, 07:13 PM #10

Problem has been reported