F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Yes, power equals power in terms of magnitude, but it depends on context and units.

Yes, power equals power in terms of magnitude, but it depends on context and units.

Yes, power equals power in terms of magnitude, but it depends on context and units.

Pages (3): 1 2 3 Next
M
MLGGirl54
Senior Member
258
09-30-2022, 11:46 AM
#1
I often hear people mention core count and CPU generations when talking about VRM capabilities. I usually reply by saying "power is power" and that those details don’t matter for a VRM’s suitability. However, I’m curious—are there any aspects of core count or design that could affect whether a motherboard supports a 4-core R5 1500X overclocked at 90W, but not an 8-core R7 5700X at the same wattage?
M
MLGGirl54
09-30-2022, 11:46 AM #1

I often hear people mention core count and CPU generations when talking about VRM capabilities. I usually reply by saying "power is power" and that those details don’t matter for a VRM’s suitability. However, I’m curious—are there any aspects of core count or design that could affect whether a motherboard supports a 4-core R5 1500X overclocked at 90W, but not an 8-core R7 5700X at the same wattage?

S
saukeuchiuchi
Senior Member
621
09-30-2022, 12:54 PM
#2
I agree, power remains power. 90w equals 90w. I could be wrong, though.
S
saukeuchiuchi
09-30-2022, 12:54 PM #2

I agree, power remains power. 90w equals 90w. I could be wrong, though.

E
ethyum
Junior Member
1
10-11-2022, 03:54 PM
#3
the issue begins with the TDP ratings from AMD and Intel being questionable. though one CPU draws 90W through the VRM and another does the same, they’re nearly identical at comparable voltages. minor differences in VRM performance exist across voltage levels, but if you're within that narrow range where it matters, you're already operating near the edge.
E
ethyum
10-11-2022, 03:54 PM #3

the issue begins with the TDP ratings from AMD and Intel being questionable. though one CPU draws 90W through the VRM and another does the same, they’re nearly identical at comparable voltages. minor differences in VRM performance exist across voltage levels, but if you're within that narrow range where it matters, you're already operating near the edge.

M
MrSarx
Senior Member
375
10-13-2022, 12:08 AM
#4
Yes, the 90W at 12V remains accurate. However, CPU ratings today often reflect real performance rather than just numbers. Wattage isn't always a reliable indicator of capability, especially with modern features like self-boosting. The 13900K and 7950X both show higher draw under load than their listed values suggest, so actual usage matters more than static specs.
M
MrSarx
10-13-2022, 12:08 AM #4

Yes, the 90W at 12V remains accurate. However, CPU ratings today often reflect real performance rather than just numbers. Wattage isn't always a reliable indicator of capability, especially with modern features like self-boosting. The 13900K and 7950X both show higher draw under load than their listed values suggest, so actual usage matters more than static specs.

B
beutfulsk8r
Junior Member
47
10-13-2022, 04:19 PM
#5
ah yes, AMD's 65W TDP on AM5 CPUs lmao I think they mistook 65W TDP with 65W when it's just sitting in motherboard with powered off PC
B
beutfulsk8r
10-13-2022, 04:19 PM #5

ah yes, AMD's 65W TDP on AM5 CPUs lmao I think they mistook 65W TDP with 65W when it's just sitting in motherboard with powered off PC

K
Kaymary10
Member
152
10-19-2022, 10:45 PM
#6
They mention that Intel doesn't carry out the identical actions.
K
Kaymary10
10-19-2022, 10:45 PM #6

They mention that Intel doesn't carry out the identical actions.

E
EleqTRiX
Member
110
10-20-2022, 07:57 PM
#7
I understand the TDP values are misleading, which is why I mentioned the 5700X draws 90W—possibly because its actual TDP is around 65W, but its PPT reaches 88W, setting the real power limit. Yes, a 1500X with 90W won’t match a 5900X that has 105W TDP, since the latter caps at 142W. I’m assuming the CPUs are consuming similar power, not just matching the same TDP labels or naming conventions.
E
EleqTRiX
10-20-2022, 07:57 PM #7

I understand the TDP values are misleading, which is why I mentioned the 5700X draws 90W—possibly because its actual TDP is around 65W, but its PPT reaches 88W, setting the real power limit. Yes, a 1500X with 90W won’t match a 5900X that has 105W TDP, since the latter caps at 142W. I’m assuming the CPUs are consuming similar power, not just matching the same TDP labels or naming conventions.

X
xntomas
Junior Member
6
10-20-2022, 09:43 PM
#8
They likely do, but the design forces a lot of power to deliver performance while keeping things hot at around 95°C. It claims 65W TDP across 12 cores with hyperthreading and a 5,4Ghz boost, plus an integrated GPU—seems like a hefty spec for that heat.
X
xntomas
10-20-2022, 09:43 PM #8

They likely do, but the design forces a lot of power to deliver performance while keeping things hot at around 95°C. It claims 65W TDP across 12 cores with hyperthreading and a 5,4Ghz boost, plus an integrated GPU—seems like a hefty spec for that heat.

G
gamer2hokv
Member
198
10-28-2022, 04:52 PM
#9
Are you simply showing off your fandom or attempting to convey something meaningful? Up to now, you haven’t presented clear arguments.
G
gamer2hokv
10-28-2022, 04:52 PM #9

Are you simply showing off your fandom or attempting to convey something meaningful? Up to now, you haven’t presented clear arguments.

C
CryseArtz
Junior Member
45
10-29-2022, 01:43 PM
#10
I’m saying it’s absurd to assume a 65W TDP equals only 65W of power consumption, right?
C
CryseArtz
10-29-2022, 01:43 PM #10

I’m saying it’s absurd to assume a 65W TDP equals only 65W of power consumption, right?

Pages (3): 1 2 3 Next