Which Asus model is better, Dual or TUF 5070?
Which Asus model is better, Dual or TUF 5070?
I’m considering two options for an RTX 5070 (Dual OC versus TUF OC), where the TUF version is only slightly more expensive.
My current setup uses a Fractal Design Torrent Nano. The Dual OC works perfectly, but with my older card, a EVGA 3060TI XC caused overheating. To fix that, I added two Noctua Industrial fans to boost airflow—something I’m concerned might repeat with the Dual OC.
I reached out to Fractal Design about compatibility with the TUF model, noting its 62.5mm height and limited case airflow space. They said it should work, but warned that even with the bigger card, airflow limitations could still be an issue.
Deciding which card to choose is important since I plan to use it for at least five years. I want to make the best decision now.
Thanks in advance.
The DualOC won't work with any issues, but with my old card, an EVGA 3060TI XC caused problems. I added two Noctua Industrial fans to boost airflow, though I fear the same problem might repeat with the Dual OC.
The RTX 3000 line had significant temporary power spikes, suggesting more heat output. The newer RTX 5000 series has improved, and the RTX 5070 should run well.
The TUF series cards offer better quality components compared to the Dual/Prime line, which is Asus's entry-level option. You might try taking out the bottom fans and testing the TUF RTX 5070 with the fans back on to compare temperatures.
Which card should you choose?
Do you have these two as your only choices? Where are you located? What is your budget for a GPU? Which store do you prefer to buy from? What is your PSU model, make, and age?
So where I mentioned adding fans below the 3060ti, they would only fit if I chose the Dual OC version. In the TUF scenario, they wouldn’t be available—the remaining 2.5mm space is actually from the GPU to the bottom of the case where the mesh is placed.
Is the Palit one superior to the ASUS Dual in cooling, noise reduction, and component quality? I've noticed many reviews mentioning plastic parts and coil whine. I initially considered the ASUS Prime from Amazon for 600€, but it now costs 730€. Higher quality generally means fewer problems over the next five years.
I use the 4070 super version of the ASUS Dual and from what I see it matches the same cooler as the 5070 mentioned by Overclockers. The cooler and card feel much more robust compared to the lower-end MSI dual cards I've used before. The card runs very cool and remains quiet even at higher fan speeds. I've had this PC on a desk next to me, so quiet operation is essential. It has been running for nearly 18 months without any changes in noise, heat, or performance. The only thing to note is that I'm using it in a Lian Li 011D Evo case with a vertical mount, which should improve airflow. My profile picture would display the card. I would choose this over some PNY cards because the coolers in similar price ranges seem quite basic.
I have an Asus Dual 4070 Super OC. It operates very quietly. I purchased it specifically for its zero RPM feature and no RGB, since I’ve become obsessed with RGB and now dislike it. The fans only start spinning up once the GPU temperature reaches around 50-55°C. I also own a Lian Li 215, which provides excellent airflow. It has two 200mm intake fans at the front to help distribute air across the GPU. There’s a single Corsair 120SE exhaust fan at the back and CPU AIO fans mounted on top.
I understand the Dual OC in a case that has alot more space with easier directing of air to the GPU, but again I have a small case, where the airflow is quite poor, mostly being sucked from the ground through dust mesh.
I would also have the option of the ASUS Prime 5070 that I orginally wanted to order from Amazon, for £512, 580€, which would be as long as the TUF, but with the similar width of the Dual (a bit over) to allow 'better' airflow than if I went with the TUF.
Examining the situation, the card would be very near the dust filter at the base of the case, yet it seems the case is elevated sufficiently by design for air to enter from the bottom. As long as it's placed on a desk or wooden floor and not carpet, the airflow should remain adequate no matter which card you choose.
I reached out to Fractal for assistance regarding this issue, and they confirmed that thicknesses exceeding 60mm are not recommended. They also explained that the TUF would be excessively tight, leading to turbulence noise and increased temperatures.