F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Suggestions for a dual-analog hall effect controller paired with a good d-pad suitable for both modern and retro games.

Suggestions for a dual-analog hall effect controller paired with a good d-pad suitable for both modern and retro games.

Suggestions for a dual-analog hall effect controller paired with a good d-pad suitable for both modern and retro games.

H
hickerbilly15
Junior Member
Find
5
01-12-2016, 11:09 AM
#1
I'm searching for a versatile controller suitable for both contemporary PC titles and emulated vintage games. Ideally, it should offer a dual-analog setup with asymmetrical analog sticks reminiscent of an Xbox, hall-effect analog sticks, vibration feedback, and a 1009Hz refresh rate when connected directly. Having hall-effect triggers would be ideal, though the main focus is on a responsive d-pad that doesn’t feel like an afterthought—especially for controlling characters rather than just extra items.

My initial choice was the 8BitDo Xbox Ultimate Wired, which I later upgraded to the Ultimate 2C. While I thoroughly enjoy this setup for most modern games, it falls short for retro titles. The main drawback is the d-pad: it’s quite sensitive and often misinterprets diagonal inputs when pressed in a straight line.

I’ve also heard the GameSir Nova Lite competes closely with the Ultimate 2C, offering a decent d-pad, but its triggers aren’t hall-effect based, and it reportedly suffers from poor latency. There’s a rumored wired-only version, though I couldn’t confirm its existence.

The PowerA OPS V1 appears to match many of the Ultimate 2C’s strengths, including lower latency, but its d-pad remains unclear—some versions are wireless only, though it can be used wired.

I’ve explored various models like the EasySMX X05, X10, X15, and X20. The differences between them are confusing, and prices often fluctuate from their advertised costs. All these options seem compatible with a Switch, though motion control support varies. Finding reliable information about the d-pad’s performance for retro games on these modern controllers is challenging.

The X20 stands out in my research, but its MSRP is $60 and it’s frequently sold out. If only my current set of controllers offered a superior d-pad—perhaps with customizable buttons or trigger locks—I’d be ideal. Otherwise, I’m considering whether two devices might be necessary: one tailored for retro games and another for modern PC titles. (They would still need to support dual analog inputs.)

Any recommendations or insights would be greatly appreciated.
Reply
Reply
H
hickerbilly15
01-12-2016, 11:09 AM #1

I'm searching for a versatile controller suitable for both contemporary PC titles and emulated vintage games. Ideally, it should offer a dual-analog setup with asymmetrical analog sticks reminiscent of an Xbox, hall-effect analog sticks, vibration feedback, and a 1009Hz refresh rate when connected directly. Having hall-effect triggers would be ideal, though the main focus is on a responsive d-pad that doesn’t feel like an afterthought—especially for controlling characters rather than just extra items.

My initial choice was the 8BitDo Xbox Ultimate Wired, which I later upgraded to the Ultimate 2C. While I thoroughly enjoy this setup for most modern games, it falls short for retro titles. The main drawback is the d-pad: it’s quite sensitive and often misinterprets diagonal inputs when pressed in a straight line.

I’ve also heard the GameSir Nova Lite competes closely with the Ultimate 2C, offering a decent d-pad, but its triggers aren’t hall-effect based, and it reportedly suffers from poor latency. There’s a rumored wired-only version, though I couldn’t confirm its existence.

The PowerA OPS V1 appears to match many of the Ultimate 2C’s strengths, including lower latency, but its d-pad remains unclear—some versions are wireless only, though it can be used wired.

I’ve explored various models like the EasySMX X05, X10, X15, and X20. The differences between them are confusing, and prices often fluctuate from their advertised costs. All these options seem compatible with a Switch, though motion control support varies. Finding reliable information about the d-pad’s performance for retro games on these modern controllers is challenging.

The X20 stands out in my research, but its MSRP is $60 and it’s frequently sold out. If only my current set of controllers offered a superior d-pad—perhaps with customizable buttons or trigger locks—I’d be ideal. Otherwise, I’m considering whether two devices might be necessary: one tailored for retro games and another for modern PC titles. (They would still need to support dual analog inputs.)

Any recommendations or insights would be greatly appreciated.

Reply
Reply