Setting up networking for a newcomer with a modem/router and a future server in mind
Setting up networking for a newcomer with a modem/router and a future server in mind
Hello, I’m here to assist you with your networking plans. You’re considering upgrading from your current ISP-provided modem/router and setting up a future server or NAS. Let me break down your questions clearly.
1. Regarding the ASUS AIMesh router: It’s a solid choice for larger homes, offering strong coverage and smart features. ASUS is reputable in networking gear, but always check recent reviews and compatibility with your ISP’s network. TP-Link and Netgear are also good alternatives if you prefer different brands.
2. You don’t necessarily need to replace the ISP modem/router entirely. You can purchase a new router that connects via the WAN port of your existing modem, especially if it supports the same ISP. This keeps your current setup intact while giving you better performance.
3. For easy port forwarding and hosting game servers, look for a router with intuitive settings and robust forwarding options. Many modern models make this straightforward.
4. Yes, replacing the IPS modem/router is advisable if you want future-proofing and better performance. It ensures compatibility with newer devices and technologies.
5. Setting up a NAS or server will require a stable connection and sufficient bandwidth. Ensure your router supports VLANs or separate networks if needed for security.
Feel free to ask more details, and I’ll help you decide the best path!
I’d start by leaving the ISP’s hardware untouched if possible. They’re familiar with their equipment and might not understand what you purchase. Connect via Ethernet to your personal Wi-Fi router instead, then isolate your network from the ISP’s. That way, you’ll have full control.
1: gather several high-quality access points and place them in important areas like the living room.
2: I usually keep the ISP equipment there if it simplifies getting help when needed.
3: it varies by provider—some work well independently, others you might want to isolate your device behind a firewall.
4: do you mean connecting people online, such as friends or relatives, or is it for public services?
Thanks for your reply, Manikyath. I think the ACER option could work well. Did you have another suggestion in mind? 2. I agree, it sounds like a solid plan based on what you and Bombastinator mentioned. 3. If I connect my router to the ISP's network and it's a good one, would that mean the ISP's equipment is outdated? 4. For people in different towns, we should consider their specific setups.
They’re usually not viewed that way. It’s more about selecting a model. Consider the devices you plan to connect and how they might block or weaken the radio signal. Different naming conventions carry distinct characteristics. Currently, I see it as a decision between Wi-Fi 5, 6, and the upcoming Wi-Fi 7 is expected soon. There are also various proprietary solutions that can boost speeds but often require specific hardware from the manufacturer, sometimes causing interference. A Wi-Fi 7 router might exist, but if it’s their exclusive version, it could be Wi-Fi 6 with features similar to Wi-Fi 7 but not quite the same. Non-standard options tend to be ineffective.
1) ASUS offers the top MESH setup I've encountered, since most setups aren't locked into rigid systems like those from Netgear or Google. Still, many enthusiasts build MESH networks, making it more about personal choice.
2) The setup isn’t all-or-nothing. You can switch your ISP’s gateway if needed. In the US, cable companies often permit home gateways and standard modems, while DSL, Fiber, or Cellular providers may require you to use their hardware. Some charge extra for rentals—Comcast, for instance, bills around $14 monthly. Other services like Charter once offered free modems but added fees for Wi-Fi. If your ISP doesn’t cover it or you must use their gear, consider enabling bridge mode or IP Pass Thru to avoid double NAT problems.
3) When using an ISP gateway, switch it to bridge mode or IP Pass Thru. This helps prevent complications with port forwarding when connecting a router to the gateway.
Gateway refers to the modem/router setup. When you have a gateway, it includes an integrated router, so connecting another router gives you two firewalls and double NAT, which complicates port forwarding. Bridge mode or IP pass-through mode basically disables the router part.
I believe I understand how to arrange everything now. Just one more thing—can I receive only a modem from my ISP provider and a router from ASUS, then connect them together? I’m curious because it would be simpler for me, especially since modems are more available locally and cheaper.
As long as you can configure the ISP device to operate in bridge mode, it will function solely as a modem. You could also place your own router behind the ISP when it doubles as a router, but this may create complications with double NAT. If the ISP is merely a modem, it simply facilitates traffic between your router and the ISP without altering anything. Opting for simplicity is advisable. It's easy to become overly complex when managing home networking.
AT&T doesn't provide that feature. They just have a gateway, and most ISPs work similarly. Using IP pass through is essentially the sole option available.