F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks s about WiFi mesh networks

s about WiFi mesh networks

s about WiFi mesh networks

Pages (2): 1 2 Next
W
WD_Trashster
Senior Member
454
01-03-2016, 04:59 AM
#1
Hey there, friend. I see you're trying to set up a Wi-Fi mesh network without swapping your current ISP gear. That sounds like a smart move—keeping your existing modem and router intact makes sense. Since your ISP charges for their own extender kit, you're looking for a way to extend coverage using something more flexible. I checked out TP OneMesh and Asus AiMesh, but both seem to need a dedicated hub/router as the central point. That might feel a bit too much if you're not comfortable with that setup. You mentioned you'd like a solution that acts like a bridge or mesh node, maybe even something that could work with your existing router via Ethernet. I’m not sure if a simple router is enough for this, but there are options out there that let you connect multiple devices and create a seamless network without a full hub. If you're open to it, I can dig up some simpler alternatives or guides that fit your needs. Just let me know!
W
WD_Trashster
01-03-2016, 04:59 AM #1

Hey there, friend. I see you're trying to set up a Wi-Fi mesh network without swapping your current ISP gear. That sounds like a smart move—keeping your existing modem and router intact makes sense. Since your ISP charges for their own extender kit, you're looking for a way to extend coverage using something more flexible. I checked out TP OneMesh and Asus AiMesh, but both seem to need a dedicated hub/router as the central point. That might feel a bit too much if you're not comfortable with that setup. You mentioned you'd like a solution that acts like a bridge or mesh node, maybe even something that could work with your existing router via Ethernet. I’m not sure if a simple router is enough for this, but there are options out there that let you connect multiple devices and create a seamless network without a full hub. If you're open to it, I can dig up some simpler alternatives or guides that fit your needs. Just let me know!

O
OverHead02
Junior Member
2
01-05-2016, 04:57 AM
#2
I’m curious about whether you actually need a mesh network. They can be pricey and might not cover every part of your home well. I’d suggest a plug-and-play access point or wireless router if that’s enough. If the coverage isn’t sufficient and you prefer avoiding cables, a mesh system could be the ideal choice.
O
OverHead02
01-05-2016, 04:57 AM #2

I’m curious about whether you actually need a mesh network. They can be pricey and might not cover every part of your home well. I’d suggest a plug-and-play access point or wireless router if that’s enough. If the coverage isn’t sufficient and you prefer avoiding cables, a mesh system could be the ideal choice.

S
sniperboy650
Senior Member
735
01-06-2016, 05:41 AM
#3
Technically it could function. However, since your ISP box acts as a router, inserting another router would result in double NAT. This can lead to problems with port forwarding and certain services. Ideally you'd want a regular modem, or if you have fiber, a standard ONT with a router. But with fiber, you must use the equipment provided by your ISP—either bridge mode or pass-through mode—which depends on their setup.
S
sniperboy650
01-06-2016, 05:41 AM #3

Technically it could function. However, since your ISP box acts as a router, inserting another router would result in double NAT. This can lead to problems with port forwarding and certain services. Ideally you'd want a regular modem, or if you have fiber, a standard ONT with a router. But with fiber, you must use the equipment provided by your ISP—either bridge mode or pass-through mode—which depends on their setup.

P
PatSArang
Junior Member
19
01-06-2016, 08:29 AM
#4
This setup seems complicated because all the mesh options depend on a full router acting as the central controller. It feels like you need a separate device connected via Ethernet, which adds complexity and cost. If your ISP router already works well for you, why would you need another router? It sounds like you're looking for a simpler, plug-and-play solution instead.
P
PatSArang
01-06-2016, 08:29 AM #4

This setup seems complicated because all the mesh options depend on a full router acting as the central controller. It feels like you need a separate device connected via Ethernet, which adds complexity and cost. If your ISP router already works well for you, why would you need another router? It sounds like you're looking for a simpler, plug-and-play solution instead.

R
Rhuji
Senior Member
437
01-10-2016, 11:47 PM
#5
Most mesh systems are custom-built. For mesh, it doesn’t always behave as expected. WiFi boosters seem to function well, but they’re not ideal solutions.
R
Rhuji
01-10-2016, 11:47 PM #5

Most mesh systems are custom-built. For mesh, it doesn’t always behave as expected. WiFi boosters seem to function well, but they’re not ideal solutions.

I
iinfo
Junior Member
9
01-11-2016, 03:22 AM
#6
The issue likely stems from each extender maintaining its own SSID without a mesh controller managing them.
I
iinfo
01-11-2016, 03:22 AM #6

The issue likely stems from each extender maintaining its own SSID without a mesh controller managing them.

P
pixlpanda
Junior Member
14
01-11-2016, 09:17 AM
#7
They reduced your bandwidth to half. The same radio that connects to the router also communicates with devices linked to the extender. In a mesh setup there are distinct radios for router and client use, each with its own SSID. They also limit the range so the extender stays close enough for a stable connection; otherwise it slows down.
P
pixlpanda
01-11-2016, 09:17 AM #7

They reduced your bandwidth to half. The same radio that connects to the router also communicates with devices linked to the extender. In a mesh setup there are distinct radios for router and client use, each with its own SSID. They also limit the range so the extender stays close enough for a stable connection; otherwise it slows down.

X
xXRadiationz
Junior Member
7
01-11-2016, 09:51 AM
#8
Can Ethernet extend to areas with weaker Wi-Fi signals? Yes, you can set up access points or switch mesh networks into AP mode. For the mesh option, most systems support it when connected via a wired link to a current router.
X
xXRadiationz
01-11-2016, 09:51 AM #8

Can Ethernet extend to areas with weaker Wi-Fi signals? Yes, you can set up access points or switch mesh networks into AP mode. For the mesh option, most systems support it when connected via a wired link to a current router.

S
sniperboy650
Senior Member
735
01-11-2016, 03:47 PM
#9
Linus mentioned in the review that Deco satellites must always connect to the master, but I wondered if they could actually "daisy chain" them. The only proof I found online was this link: https://community.tp-link.com/en/home/fo...pic/174580
S
sniperboy650
01-11-2016, 03:47 PM #9

Linus mentioned in the review that Deco satellites must always connect to the master, but I wondered if they could actually "daisy chain" them. The only proof I found online was this link: https://community.tp-link.com/en/home/fo...pic/174580

M
MC_MAN723
Junior Member
16
01-11-2016, 04:45 PM
#10
One of the devices serves as a master, usually linked to the modem. The remaining units are slaves, capable of connecting via wired or wireless to the master. All mesh devices have a master unit, which is the standard setup. You won’t find a mesh system that integrates with your ISP’s gateway, as most mesh solutions are proprietary. If you wish to use your ISP’s gateway in gateway mode and have mesh that supports it, you must adopt their specific solution. For third-party options, you’ll need to configure the ISP’s equipment in bridge mode or, in some cases, switch to pass-through mode if it doesn’t support it.
M
MC_MAN723
01-11-2016, 04:45 PM #10

One of the devices serves as a master, usually linked to the modem. The remaining units are slaves, capable of connecting via wired or wireless to the master. All mesh devices have a master unit, which is the standard setup. You won’t find a mesh system that integrates with your ISP’s gateway, as most mesh solutions are proprietary. If you wish to use your ISP’s gateway in gateway mode and have mesh that supports it, you must adopt their specific solution. For third-party options, you’ll need to configure the ISP’s equipment in bridge mode or, in some cases, switch to pass-through mode if it doesn’t support it.

Pages (2): 1 2 Next