Router & Home Network Assistance / Advice
Router & Home Network Assistance / Advice
I was using YouTube as background while the rest of the video kept playing. While searching for the best upgrades for my home tools—especially a brushless Milwaukee—I caught someone say, "Who uses the one from their ISP?" That sparked my curiosity. Back when I lived alone in a basement suite, the modem/router from Shaw was right next to my PC, and the WiFi reached all areas of the house. I never thought about getting a separate router. But now that I own a new home with my girlfriend, I’m wondering the same.
In the past, ISPs only offered modems with limited ports and no WiFi support, so adding a router was standard. But as ISPs began adding WiFi and upgrading modems into larger devices, I assumed they were sufficient.
Here’s my take: My house is about 2,500 sq ft across two levels. When I was renovating, the router was in the garage. We have Shaw fibre 300 and a small modem/router with two ports that also supports WiFi. If we move into the house on June 1st, I plan to relocate the fibre line to a more central spot—maybe upstairs in the living room or downstairs in the TV room.
Could there be a better location for the fibre line to support other router options? What would you suggest for good WiFi coverage? The port count isn’t critical; I’m assuming at least four ports are enough. I don’t have a tight budget, but I could spend $100–$150 right now and another $100–$150 soon after finishing more home improvements.
My current setup includes an LG nano90 Smart TV (wireless), a Nintendo Switch (wireless), a Playstation 4 (wireless), plus a DVD player, two smartphones, and two laptops.
I think the router works adequately for your needs, but you'll need another AP to boost your wireless range. I often suggest Ubiquiti since they offer a solid mix of features and ease for users, though it does come with some quirks—like the need to install a controller (though not constantly required unless you use captive portals or other specific functions). Improving the fiber connection to place the router optimally and enhance WiFi performance can be quite time-consuming and expensive.
It appears Shaw operates as a cable service adhering to the Docsis standard. This simplifies the process. You must determine whether to swap the ISP equipment or operate it in bridge mode (modem-only). Upgrading is largely up to your ISP. I’m uncertain about Canada’s rules for customer-owned gear. In the US, FCC rules allow it with coaxial internet, making relocation straightforward. If you switch to bridge mode and treat it as a modem, just connect an Ethernet cable to the router. Theoretically, you could keep the existing line and extend it via Ethernet to a central point. Besides those options, ASUS routers are compatible with AI mesh systems, enabling flexible network configurations.
I've never considered switching to a different ISP setup. Usually I just turn off their WiFi and set up my own router. Regarding bridge mode, it looks like the easiest choice I have right now. The Google Nest bundle seems appealing because they already understand me well, so I’m okay with them having more of their services monitoring my odd conversations. What are the main downsides to using equipment from the ISP? Why do people advise moving away from them?
My internet provider bills $13 each month, but $25 for unlimited data. They also provide hidden access to your device and network. Since Comcast can see what’s connected to the gateway and other network details, I prefer using my own equipment.