F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks OpenWRT vs Mikrotik for home user?

OpenWRT vs Mikrotik for home user?

OpenWRT vs Mikrotik for home user?

B
banshee45
Senior Member
Find
726
04-13-2023, 05:13 PM
#1
In short, I'm searching for a decent router with some advanced QoS features to prioritize gaming and calls. I need VLAN support for guest segmentation and possibly ALS. Since my internet will eventually be around 150 Mbps, I'm looking for something that fits. The options I have are: Mikrotik RB750GR3 (~60$), Ruijie Reyee RG-EG105G-V3 (~63$), a surprisingly affordable used OpenWRT model from JCG Q20 (~14$), and another budget OpenWRT unit. For the most value, which one should I choose? I think Mikrotik/Reyee are solid for reliability, but OpenWRT could work well at such a low price. The JCG Q20 has fewer ports but can be replaced with a smart switch if needed. I'm planning to connect 2 PCs on gigabit LAN, possibly 4-6 phones, plus a guest Wi-Fi, a CCTV, and a Linux NAS/server. There might also be some IoT devices.
Reply
Reply
B
banshee45
04-13-2023, 05:13 PM #1

In short, I'm searching for a decent router with some advanced QoS features to prioritize gaming and calls. I need VLAN support for guest segmentation and possibly ALS. Since my internet will eventually be around 150 Mbps, I'm looking for something that fits. The options I have are: Mikrotik RB750GR3 (~60$), Ruijie Reyee RG-EG105G-V3 (~63$), a surprisingly affordable used OpenWRT model from JCG Q20 (~14$), and another budget OpenWRT unit. For the most value, which one should I choose? I think Mikrotik/Reyee are solid for reliability, but OpenWRT could work well at such a low price. The JCG Q20 has fewer ports but can be replaced with a smart switch if needed. I'm planning to connect 2 PCs on gigabit LAN, possibly 4-6 phones, plus a guest Wi-Fi, a CCTV, and a Linux NAS/server. There might also be some IoT devices.

Reply
Reply
S
Sarluc
Junior Member
Find
42
04-14-2023, 01:48 AM
#2
They all rely on the same SoC, making the choice about interface preference the main concern. For me, MikroTik stands out—it's strong and dependable, well-supported, and has a big community, though it demands some networking skills. I wouldn't risk it for international brands.
Reply
Reply
S
Sarluc
04-14-2023, 01:48 AM #2

They all rely on the same SoC, making the choice about interface preference the main concern. For me, MikroTik stands out—it's strong and dependable, well-supported, and has a big community, though it demands some networking skills. I wouldn't risk it for international brands.

Reply
Reply