Not sure which router to choose? Consider your needs and compare options carefully.
Not sure which router to choose? Consider your needs and compare options carefully.
We’ve been using the standard router provided by Xfinity for our internet plan, which worked okay for a while but now struggles with performance. Devices are losing connection, the router frequently crashes, and we’re looking to upgrade. I’m new to networking—I don’t even know if it falls into that category. What I understand is that we have several smart TVs streaming, multiple game consoles, at least one downloading content or playing online games, four phones constantly browsing or watching YouTube/Netflix, and three computers, two of which are often gaming-focused. My main concern seems to be bandwidth limitations, so I’d like a router that can handle our family size—around seven people when guests visit. I’m aware my PC, my brother’s PC, and his Samsung TV tend to have connection problems, while the others run smoothly. My PC uses a $30 Netgear antenna for Wi-Fi, and my brother has a $50 one; both often drop connections completely. If you could suggest some router options and tips for improving our PC connections, as well as recommendations for TVs, that would be really helpful. I’d prefer to stay under $200, and the cheapest choice shouldn’t be terrible.
Xfinity provides a gateway instead of renting a router, which includes both modem and router functions. You’d need to purchase either a gateway or a standard cable modem along with a router. I tend to go with the latter. USB WiFi adapters are generally unreliable; PCIe models perform better but may be more complex for beginners. Interference from various sources can disrupt WiFi connections, making quality adapters crucial. A solid router is essential, but it’s not enough on its own. As @RAM555789 mentioned, Ethernet offers the most stable performance. Wiring devices that support Ethernet reduces reliance on WiFi for those connections. My Synology RT2600 AC has worked well, though it fits within a $200 budget. A slightly slower model is available at a lower price but still delivers strong speeds due to its inclusion in the AC standard. Router effectiveness depends on several factors: room size, number of walls separating router and devices, wall materials (drywall vs concrete), nearby networks operating on similar frequencies, signal interference from other sources, device radio quality, and weather conditions—especially for 2.4GHz signals which can weaken with rain or storms.
Poor weather conditions can disrupt signals within a home by damaging infrastructure, causing interference, or reducing transmission quality.
Air moisture is likely connected to humidity. This is based on my own observations. I've noticed storms passing through while my PC used WiFi, and the connection quality dropped noticeably during bad weather.
Thanks for the feedback. Your location in MN means winters tend to be dry yet chilly, while summers are usually humid. Your home is a typical middle-class size with several walls—mostly wood and drywall. You’ve been using Ethernet for your PC but recently had a dog that chews on cables, causing damage. Since the wiring isn’t in your house, you can’t install new connections through walls or floors. You’re considering a PCIe card but have found many reviews negative due to budget constraints. Someone suggested finding a new one. You live in a moderately populated suburb near the city, which likely increases interference.
I've experienced problems with Comcast during strong winds, which would disrupt our signal and sometimes affect TV connections. Once the wind subsided, service usually resumed. It seems Verizon uses fiber instead, though we haven't encountered similar issues recently.
The wind is coming in. Your device and connection are safe inside. What's up?