Networking Noob
Networking Noob
Sorry, I missed addressing your question. You’ll know when you need a managed switch. You’re exploring VLANs or link aggregation and realized your device can’t handle those tasks. The main distinction from other routers and Wi-Fi is that you’ve got a ready-made solution—most setup has been handled for you, it’s easy to start with, but the downside is limited customization. If the pre-built version doesn’t fit your requirements, options are limited. Another factor is the quality of parts and how much traffic the gadget can manage at once. If you’re keen on networking, consider getting a used PC with two Ethernet ports and installing pfSense. For managed switches, the TP-link TL-SG108E is a good choice—it’s $35 on Amazon and covers your basics for VLANs and trunking.
I was just wondering what I’d end up with eventually. Maybe in a few years I’ll have a clearer idea. Also, I should have reworded myself since calling them “overkill routers” meant basic devices that fit into a rack mount along with a power strip, patch panel, and switch.
Another excellent option is Mikrotik Routerboards, offering numerous features ideal for small network labs. They support VLANs and LAG, along with many additional capabilities. I incorporate them in several networking courses I conduct. They serve as a strong learning tool and function effectively as home networking gear. Keep in mind they are highly configurable, which can be daunting, but the Mikrotik Wiki and Forums provide excellent guidance. Many users here also rely on them.