Modem → Ethernet-only router → wireless access point?
Modem → Ethernet-only router → wireless access point?
Sure thing! Here’s a clearer version of your thoughts:
Thanks for the feedback. I was confused about the installation details—some steps were labeled differently than others. I’m leaning toward using the Arris S33, Motorola MB8611, or Netgear CM1200 modem, depending on what offers the best value when I have the money. For the router, the Mikrotek RB5009UG+S+IN seems solid. I’d like a 2.5Gbps port for now and an SFP+ option for later upgrades. The wireless AP will stay as my current all-in-one unit in AP mode until I get better equipment. Overall, it looks like a reasonable choice that should help me stay ahead in the future.
When you're focused on immediate needs, quicker networking shouldn't be a top priority unless it directly leads to better income or career growth through IT skills. Most websites already offer speeds that meet the average user's requirements. Trying to boost download speeds beyond typical offerings usually costs more than the benefits. For example, upgrading to 2.5Gbps or 10Gbps might cost hundreds for equipment and several hundred more per device, totaling around $1000 plus ongoing service fees. Networking devices often last longer, but future-proofing isn't always reliable, especially with evolving tech like wall cabling. I spent money on a 10GbE switch during the pandemic, along with NICs and cables, aiming to centralize storage on a NAS, but it wasn't worth the expense.
I'm not sure what you're referring to exactly. The media converter works best when it's simply converting one type of connection to another, like cable to Ethernet or DSL to Ethernet. In reality, a modem and gateway are quite similar in both hardware and software, with the main difference being software-based bridging. After that, a router is usually needed. I tend to choose devices I can set up fully myself without being locked into any vendor's restrictions. That's why I chose Zyxel for its transparency on AP client rates and why I dislike Ubiquiti controllers—they push you toward buying their products by highlighting features you can't use, making them unnecessarily large and complicated. On the positive side, I've heard good things about Mikrotik; it's worth noting that with an x86 device you can switch the router's operating system at your discretion if needed. Many users have switched from pfSense to OPNsense because of issues at Netgate. Also, upgrading to newer hardware gives you a backup PC for customization instead of ending up with e-waste. It comes with a 12V 3A PSU, so it's limited to around 32W and won't consume much power if used at all.
Based on my observations, they tend to overheat, struggle with WiFi speed, and if they’re provided by your ISP, setup can be quite challenging. Most features are accessible through the web portal, while other options require using the Comcast app. Also, the modems seem to have a long lifespan, but network standards and Ethernet specifications can evolve, making it simpler to upgrade the router part without needing a new modem for your account. Comcast has made this process slightly more complicated over time. The S33 is described as a standard 2.5 Gbps Ethernet model with no issues.
Acknowledging this, an ISP router in bridge mode should look identical to a modem. The issue lies with questionable ISPs that charge for rental, though that varies by location. If they don’t, using ISP gear in bridge mode can be convenient since replacements are required if it fails—your responsibility. On the flip side, in places like the UK, cable modems aren’t available for purchase; they’re bundled with free installation for new customers but push you toward newer models from the provider, even if compatibility is limited. Threatening to cancel often resolves such concerns. Fortunately, UK fiber providers supply their own ONTs, so failures are the provider’s issue—just plug in your own router. Even with DSL options that mix self-installed and ISP-provided devices, not all ISPs are known for poor support, though some still face criticism.