Memory problems reported with Strix X570-E device.
Memory problems reported with Strix X570-E device.
I received this kit from Reddit a few weeks back, and it’s been functioning well in my games. But this morning I was stress-testing a GPU with Furmark and encountered some BSODs, which likely point to memory problems. The memtests indicate errors at XMP settings, even when I set it to 1.4V or forced 2T instead of the automatic 1T+geardown. I understand QVLs aren’t crucial, though these issues did appear on the board’s QVL twice. https://dlcdnets.asus.com/pub/ASUS/mb/So...190912.pdf Any other steps you could suggest to verify compatibility? My CPU is an R5 3600, confirmed stable at 1800 fclk with other RAM. I set all memory settings to factory defaults, just enabling DOCP, and overheating shouldn’t be a concern with my P500A. Thanks for any advice!
I see why so many people choose this kit, but it doesn’t work well. There are plenty of problems—just read through this section repeatedly for details. The version you’d want is without the “C” at the end and would cost a bit more, around B-Die. Consider 3200mhz, check stability and OC adjustments from there. Good luck!
Ah, I wasn't aware it's a basic kit. I've noticed the 16-19-19-39 set often recommended for Ryzen, and I thought Hynix C die was at least decent.
I own this exact set. It's solid, though not the best option. The sequence 3600 16 16 16 36 suggests a specific memory configuration, possibly tied to the looser bin for kit 16 19 19 39, which may support various memory types. Without precise details about the IC in your kit, performance can differ based on production timing and operating conditions. Your Hynix CJR module should handle 3733 16 19 19 36, assuming your design meets the requirements. Could you share your Vsoc, VDDC IOD, and VDDR?
Fair point, but ASUS has plenty of 3600MHz dual and quad configurations confirmed on this board. It could be a kit issue, though I’m not sure how to tell. This is the same board I used for OC 2x16GB DDR4 to a 3600C14, but these aren’t new—just at least a year old (the price sticker says $250, hehe). I’ll check the manufacturing date on the dimms next time I reboot. All voltages are set to auto, here’s a snapshot from Ryzen Master: nothing out of the ordinary. Maybe tweaking higher and lower settings could help. I’ve also got a couple of burner shots—first one and another here. These are the first Hynix ICs I’ve tried, nothing familiar. If they’re not C die, maybe it’s bad luck today?
However, your IMC differs significantly from the testing CPU, which was likely an AMD handpicked processor. For overclocking, you'll want memory in this sequence: RAM, then Hynix, DJR, CJR. B-Die (Samsung) Rev.E (Micron), SK Hynix, and finally your build. Aim for a 3600MHz system with 16GB from B-Die's dual sticks. Using single-rank modules will help maximize bandwidth and push performance further. Feel free to skip the 4000MHz mark if you're targeting higher speeds. This is my take—adjust as needed. If you prefer a 32GB build with RGB lighting, modify the kit by removing the "C" from the end.
I'm looking at a decision point where I'd allocate around $400-450 to a CPU. That would likely mean a used 10850K or a 5800X, or I could stretch the budget for a 5900X. While I'm open to a 5900X, I don't think it's the smart choice for a purely gaming setup, even with lots of CPU-heavy titles. The 5600X vs 10600K comparison from GamersNexus showed solid gains, so I'm curious about how the 10850K/10900K would perform with similar tuning. Steve mentioned the importance of memory ranks, so sticking with 2x16GB seems solid for overclocking while still gaining dual rank benefits. Any advice on the best path forward? Maybe even starting with a 3900X could work for now.
You're after maximum performance for your gaming setup. A 5600X offers substantial RAM, but stability at 3200MHz is key. Expect potential speeds around 16-18-18, depending on the setup. Intel's current lineup spans from the 3000 series to the 5000 series, offering solid value. My experience shows an overclocked 8700K performs better than some newer models, so a 3900X might not be ideal for gaming.
You've run multiple memory tests and consistently got the same errors, no matter the clock speed. Memtest86 keeps reporting the same issues even at 2133 MHz. The test ran smoothly at 3600C14 previously, so it's possible the problem lies in the chip itself. Replacing the CPU in the socket might resolve the issue.