Mac user on Windows machine Office running on Windows Windows system with Mac integration
Mac user on Windows machine Office running on Windows Windows system with Mac integration
Der_HauiHD
07-16-2023, 06:41 AM #1Hey everyone, I'm looking for someone who's experienced with mixed OS office environments. I currently work as a video editor for a company using only MAC systems and have a chance to upgrade my workstation. I'm curious if there are any workflow issues I might face that I'm not aware of. I started with a MacBook Pro but now have the option to choose another model, hoping to avoid complications. I know some software doesn't run equally well on both platforms, so I'd need to adapt. Also, I won't have AirDrop available as it sometimes does, and I'm not sure if Apple will release updates for their new AMD GPUs soon—something that happened with my 2018 MacBook. Any thoughts?
GamingJulianHD
08-01-2023, 02:13 AM #2Davinci and Adobe perform similarly across mac and windows typically, so compatibility issues shouldn't arise. Apple is intensifying its efforts, making it hard to predict the GPU developments. If you purchased an Intel MacBook in 2020, observe what happened with PowerPC—likely abandoned within a few years.
Just learned DaVinci doesn't export ProRes on Windows yet. I'll need to dig deeper. I recall Premiere had ProRes available on Windows in CC19 or 20, and I'm curious if Adobe has added it to AE as well. I'm not sure what the future holds for ARM technology... they seem confident they can adapt, but the conference announcement made me wonder if recompiling programs at installation would maintain quality—possibly even improve it. It seems improbable they'll match today's top-tier performance on ARM processors compared to their current Intel and AMD offerings. If ARM chips could deliver that level of speed, more companies might enter the market beyond just Intel, AMD, and Nvidia. I remember the past when Intel GPUs were limited by power constraints; Apple is finally breaking that barrier with its portable devices, which now run at 60-90W. On the other hand, I'm hoping for a better GPU in the new iMACs so I can get more professional-grade editing without compromising battery life.
Davinci for windows does indeed not support exporting to prores because apple refuses to give them a license for it. So people just export the project and let ffmpeg encode it to prores. This has been the workaround for any program not having it. On the windows side intel has nothing to compete with a 4800h (part from their massive powerhungry 8core that is only faster when it those thicc boi gaming laptops might as well just get the clevo ryzen desktop cpu laptop then as it's usually lighter than those laptops and performs better :p). Sucks that apple isn't going amd.
I just looked up what ffmpeg does and it’s actually quite different from what I expected. I’m not doing any transcode every time. It’s true that I’m mainly using Davici for grading (still getting the hang of it) and not for delivery, which means there aren’t many output options but it’s too much effort. Are you someone who edits or colors and uses a similar solution? Honestly, I wouldn’t even think about buying those “thicc boi gaming laptops.” Maybe something like a Dell XPS or a MacBook would be better, though that makes things even simpler. I’ll need to do more research before deciding. Right now it seems like I’ll have to stay in the Apple box a while longer. Even though I don’t like spending so much for average performance.
xdHammodixd
08-28-2023, 09:40 AM #6The xmg core 15 amd version is slightly heavier than the xps but prevents the laptop's severe overheating issue, making the cheaper option a better choice since performance remains similar thanks to improved cooling. I don’t edit for minor tweaks and rarely use it or record audio back, so I skip it.
) What are your thoughts? I’m still unsure about some workflow compatibility and potential incompatibilities, but I think this could work if we adjust things accordingly.
DieEneDionYT
08-28-2023, 10:04 AM #7I really need at least two or more Thunderbolt ports on the laptop since there are many devices I might want to connect to while shooting. That’s why the XPS seems like the only viable option. I’ve checked some AMD models which perform well at a lower cost, but they lack some premium features and build quality. I believe this is the most compelling argument I can make to my boss: it’s around $1,000 more than the 16" MacBook we were considering, yet this machine should match its performance (possibly even surpass it thanks to the GPU) and the PC appears to be one of the top editing setups available. (except for the 3090, I couldn’t afford it due to budget limits ) What are your thoughts? I’m still unsure about some workflow compatibility and potential incompatibilities, but I think this could work if we adjust things accordingly.
The XPS 15 works decently for video work but tends to get very hot. It’s not ideal compared to other laptops. For a desktop, consider these points: 1. A PSU costing around 200€ might be reasonable, but you can find better options without sacrificing performance. 2. If you need a motherboard, avoid the threadripper type and opt for an AM4 board like the MSI Tomahawk B550 instead. 3. For video editing, a PCIe 4.0 SSD isn’t essential—an SX8200 will suffice and lets you use larger drives. The case matters too; a good airflow design helps keep things cool and quieter. Lian Li’s Lancool 215 has big fans that move a lot of air while staying relatively quiet, especially if the RGB is off. As for your RAM speed, it runs at around 3.0–3.5 GHz depending on the model.
I prefer purchasing a reliable PSU and won't cut corners on that component in a 3000eur project. I still have to verify it against the forum's PSU list. Maybe I can reduce it to 1000w now that the 3090 model is no longer available. You're correct about the motherboard—I was considering the x570 but opted for the threadripper instead. I require Thunderbolt and 10Gbps ports; B-series boards don't support those. While I don't need the extra 4.0 speed, I also won't exceed 2TB. I agree with you that quieter fans would help, though the lian-li you mentioned isn't in stock. I'm thinking more carefully now. I just chose something familiar and suitable. RAM is set to 3600MHz.
AskedRumble52
08-29-2023, 10:56 AM #10I'll provide a PCPartPicker list you can adjust as needed. Be careful not to overspend on the power supply or use excessive wattage—it reduces efficiency and forces the PSU to draw more power. Keeping things balanced is always ideal. Also, higher wattage increases size, which can lead to clearance problems.