F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks Looking for a fresh router? Here are some ideas.

Looking for a fresh router? Here are some ideas.

Looking for a fresh router? Here are some ideas.

M
Marinated
Senior Member
666
06-06-2023, 03:54 AM
#1
Your router failed, and you're considering the Netgear Nighthawk x10. Is it too much for your needs, or are there more suitable options? Other recommendations are available if you'd like. Thanks!
M
Marinated
06-06-2023, 03:54 AM #1

Your router failed, and you're considering the Netgear Nighthawk x10. Is it too much for your needs, or are there more suitable options? Other recommendations are available if you'd like. Thanks!

Z
zMadeus
Posting Freak
755
06-06-2023, 12:14 PM
#2
I wouldn’t use that equipment with a 40-foot pole, not just because of cost or brand, but since 802.11ad is set to be superseded by an updated standard called 802.11ay this year. If you’re after the newest technology, wait for it to get officially recognized. Of course, this only matters if your devices don’t already support 802.11ad or ay protocols—consider that when deciding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_Alliance#WiGig Nonetheless, I generally prefer Netgear and ASUS products because many (though not all) run OpenWRT or DD-WRT Linux firmware, giving you greater control and monitoring options, plus advanced capabilities like built-in Transmission-BT for easy NAS setups. (A dedicated NAS remains ideal, but this feature is handy for torrent servers that don’t need constant full PC operation, saving power too.) We still need more details—what’s the size of your home? Are there any dead zones or basements? How many devices are in use and what types are they? Where is your modem/router positioned, and can it be relocated if needed? If relocation isn’t possible, would you consider a mesh networking system instead?
Z
zMadeus
06-06-2023, 12:14 PM #2

I wouldn’t use that equipment with a 40-foot pole, not just because of cost or brand, but since 802.11ad is set to be superseded by an updated standard called 802.11ay this year. If you’re after the newest technology, wait for it to get officially recognized. Of course, this only matters if your devices don’t already support 802.11ad or ay protocols—consider that when deciding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_Alliance#WiGig Nonetheless, I generally prefer Netgear and ASUS products because many (though not all) run OpenWRT or DD-WRT Linux firmware, giving you greater control and monitoring options, plus advanced capabilities like built-in Transmission-BT for easy NAS setups. (A dedicated NAS remains ideal, but this feature is handy for torrent servers that don’t need constant full PC operation, saving power too.) We still need more details—what’s the size of your home? Are there any dead zones or basements? How many devices are in use and what types are they? Where is your modem/router positioned, and can it be relocated if needed? If relocation isn’t possible, would you consider a mesh networking system instead?

M
mr_WeTStoun
Junior Member
11
06-08-2023, 03:47 PM
#3
60 GHz WiFi offers no real benefit. It won’t pass through walls effectively. That’s why Linus showed up with his Wireless AD demo—some routers failed to reach the cardboard box. Better go with AC or keep an eye on future AX models.
M
mr_WeTStoun
06-08-2023, 03:47 PM #3

60 GHz WiFi offers no real benefit. It won’t pass through walls effectively. That’s why Linus showed up with his Wireless AD demo—some routers failed to reach the cardboard box. Better go with AC or keep an eye on future AX models.

T
Th3G4merX
Senior Member
700
06-16-2023, 08:44 AM
#4
In our organization we're aiming for complete isolation. No external access, no communication between systems, fully separate applications. That's exactly what we need.
T
Th3G4merX
06-16-2023, 08:44 AM #4

In our organization we're aiming for complete isolation. No external access, no communication between systems, fully separate applications. That's exactly what we need.

C
CrazyXD
Member
70
06-16-2023, 08:13 PM
#5
The responses to your inquiries are as follows:
1. Your home measures roughly thirty feet in length, positioned at the uppermost level on one side. It spans three levels, and there are no designated "dead" areas; though the signal is weak in the basement at the opposite end, an AP will eventually be placed there, which isn’t an issue.
2. The Linksys Control Panel indicates roughly 15 to 20 devices are active concurrently, mainly smartphones and tablets, with most connected via Amazon Echo devices.
3. Your modem and router are currently situated on the top floor at one end of the house. Relocating them would simply move them to the basement in a similar location.
4. We plan to add APs eventually, possibly when we acquire a new router or if we decide later. I’d rather install APs than rely on a mesh system, but I’m open to suggestions. Regarding WiGig (60Gbps), it seems limited to a few compatible devices and has very short range—could it still serve as a future-proof option? Thanks.
(By the way, I missed getting back to you for a while; I was away on the weekend and didn’t check.)
Edited March 18, 2019 by Riverchiken886
Forgot something
C
CrazyXD
06-16-2023, 08:13 PM #5

The responses to your inquiries are as follows:
1. Your home measures roughly thirty feet in length, positioned at the uppermost level on one side. It spans three levels, and there are no designated "dead" areas; though the signal is weak in the basement at the opposite end, an AP will eventually be placed there, which isn’t an issue.
2. The Linksys Control Panel indicates roughly 15 to 20 devices are active concurrently, mainly smartphones and tablets, with most connected via Amazon Echo devices.
3. Your modem and router are currently situated on the top floor at one end of the house. Relocating them would simply move them to the basement in a similar location.
4. We plan to add APs eventually, possibly when we acquire a new router or if we decide later. I’d rather install APs than rely on a mesh system, but I’m open to suggestions. Regarding WiGig (60Gbps), it seems limited to a few compatible devices and has very short range—could it still serve as a future-proof option? Thanks.
(By the way, I missed getting back to you for a while; I was away on the weekend and didn’t check.)
Edited March 18, 2019 by Riverchiken886
Forgot something

N
Nikospbingo__
Member
54
06-23-2023, 11:39 AM
#6
I really appreciate the Ubiquiti equipment. Installing things like the UniFi Security Gateway, adding a POE switch, and then APs as needed provides plenty of flexibility for future upgrades. Although it's a bit pricier, I consider it a solid investment. I use this setup at my home and several family residences.
N
Nikospbingo__
06-23-2023, 11:39 AM #6

I really appreciate the Ubiquiti equipment. Installing things like the UniFi Security Gateway, adding a POE switch, and then APs as needed provides plenty of flexibility for future upgrades. Although it's a bit pricier, I consider it a solid investment. I use this setup at my home and several family residences.