F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks L3 switch suggestion?

L3 switch suggestion?

L3 switch suggestion?

D
dannypl
Member
135
10-04-2016, 05:11 AM
#1
I need a few switches for my home network setup. Of course it's not the top-tier infrastructure, but I do require around eight ports, 1Gb/s speed (no 10G cabling), an L3 interface, and VLANs to separate the UPS from the user network. I found a suitable option on research—Netgear GS110TP-200EUS with PoE support. It has enough ports and should work well for my IP phones. If you're okay with it, keeping them separate makes sense for better management.
D
dannypl
10-04-2016, 05:11 AM #1

I need a few switches for my home network setup. Of course it's not the top-tier infrastructure, but I do require around eight ports, 1Gb/s speed (no 10G cabling), an L3 interface, and VLANs to separate the UPS from the user network. I found a suitable option on research—Netgear GS110TP-200EUS with PoE support. It has enough ports and should work well for my IP phones. If you're okay with it, keeping them separate makes sense for better management.

K
kalleboii
Senior Member
738
10-06-2016, 01:00 AM
#2
This seems to be about setting up equipment for a personal or small business setup. Most switches these days are L3 models, though you can find reasonably priced managed switches even at stores like Office Depot or Best Buy. Even the budget options from those stores usually work well for home or small business needs. Unless you require extensive PoE support or a completely reliable network without any interruptions, most everyday setups are fine. I’m working alongside our network admin who mentioned that these switches perform adequately for home or small business use. My Linksys LGS308P has been trouble-free so far.
K
kalleboii
10-06-2016, 01:00 AM #2

This seems to be about setting up equipment for a personal or small business setup. Most switches these days are L3 models, though you can find reasonably priced managed switches even at stores like Office Depot or Best Buy. Even the budget options from those stores usually work well for home or small business needs. Unless you require extensive PoE support or a completely reliable network without any interruptions, most everyday setups are fine. I’m working alongside our network admin who mentioned that these switches perform adequately for home or small business use. My Linksys LGS308P has been trouble-free so far.

J
Jessammy
Junior Member
12
10-06-2016, 07:40 AM
#3
Location. Not accessible here (no further).
J
Jessammy
10-06-2016, 07:40 AM #3

Location. Not accessible here (no further).

P
pandy28
Junior Member
17
10-07-2016, 08:51 PM
#4
You might prefer a single, bigger switch like 24 ports instead of a larger design. If you're only needing better inter-VLAN routing, you could reduce unnecessary L2 traffic by using subinterfaces or dedicated interfaces for each VLAN SVI/Gateway. I wouldn't recommend giving this kind of guidance without more context.
P
pandy28
10-07-2016, 08:51 PM #4

You might prefer a single, bigger switch like 24 ports instead of a larger design. If you're only needing better inter-VLAN routing, you could reduce unnecessary L2 traffic by using subinterfaces or dedicated interfaces for each VLAN SVI/Gateway. I wouldn't recommend giving this kind of guidance without more context.

D
DerpyPig9
Member
98
10-10-2016, 11:23 PM
#5
I really liked my Cisco SG300-10—it was affordable and had all the features you need except for dynamic routing protocols, which were only static.
D
DerpyPig9
10-10-2016, 11:23 PM #5

I really liked my Cisco SG300-10—it was affordable and had all the features you need except for dynamic routing protocols, which were only static.

C
Callysqually
Member
57
10-12-2016, 02:00 AM
#6
A L3 or Layer 3 switch is a device that supports routing functions. Current switches usually lack routing abilities, so a switch without these features isn't considered an L3 switch. Real Layer 3 switches are generally found in enterprise or carrier systems.
C
Callysqually
10-12-2016, 02:00 AM #6

A L3 or Layer 3 switch is a device that supports routing functions. Current switches usually lack routing abilities, so a switch without these features isn't considered an L3 switch. Real Layer 3 switches are generally found in enterprise or carrier systems.

S
Savage_Pig
Member
102
10-13-2016, 07:59 AM
#7
Routing isn't necessary right now. It's not available anymore. The recommended device is a CISCO SG350-10SFP 10 Port Gigabit Managed SFP Switch, costing around 230€ excluding tax. Netgear is about 100€. I don't see a need to debate the quality difference between them.
S
Savage_Pig
10-13-2016, 07:59 AM #7

Routing isn't necessary right now. It's not available anymore. The recommended device is a CISCO SG350-10SFP 10 Port Gigabit Managed SFP Switch, costing around 230€ excluding tax. Netgear is about 100€. I don't see a need to debate the quality difference between them.