F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop i7 9700k vs R7 3700X

i7 9700k vs R7 3700X

i7 9700k vs R7 3700X

Pages (2): 1 2 Next
K
Kayla0719
Member
75
02-16-2019, 02:16 PM
#1
I'm setting up a new PC and will use an RTX 2070 Super. Although the RX5700XT could offer better value, that wasn't the focus here. I need to decide between an Intel i7 9700K or a Ryzen 7 3700X, and which motherboard suits the chosen CPU. The remaining details seem appropriate: CPU, cooling requirements, a suitable motherboard, RAM, storage, graphics card, and power supply.
K
Kayla0719
02-16-2019, 02:16 PM #1

I'm setting up a new PC and will use an RTX 2070 Super. Although the RX5700XT could offer better value, that wasn't the focus here. I need to decide between an Intel i7 9700K or a Ryzen 7 3700X, and which motherboard suits the chosen CPU. The remaining details seem appropriate: CPU, cooling requirements, a suitable motherboard, RAM, storage, graphics card, and power supply.

S
Sekiel
Member
56
02-18-2019, 08:17 PM
#2
S
Sekiel
02-18-2019, 08:17 PM #2

S
Sheep_Boss
Junior Member
30
02-18-2019, 08:22 PM
#3
According to the details, it's an 8GB x4 configuration, please note that this might have been confusing
S
Sheep_Boss
02-18-2019, 08:22 PM #3

According to the details, it's an 8GB x4 configuration, please note that this might have been confusing

J
Jordi0610
Junior Member
8
02-19-2019, 04:24 AM
#4
I think this might be a personal take. You definitely need 16Gb of dual-channel RAM. The 3700X would be better for multi-threaded tasks. Instead of just a small boost in FPS on the Intel CPU, you should focus on performance gains from the Ryzen. Even with an average AAA game, you’ll likely maintain over 100 FPS thanks to the Ryzen. You might save around $200 by choosing the RX 5700/XT instead. The other boards still offer similar performance, but the TUF or Gigabyte Elite models only provide a solid base if you really need low noise levels and are willing to pay more. Avoid versions with a window unless you’re certain about your needs.
J
Jordi0610
02-19-2019, 04:24 AM #4

I think this might be a personal take. You definitely need 16Gb of dual-channel RAM. The 3700X would be better for multi-threaded tasks. Instead of just a small boost in FPS on the Intel CPU, you should focus on performance gains from the Ryzen. Even with an average AAA game, you’ll likely maintain over 100 FPS thanks to the Ryzen. You might save around $200 by choosing the RX 5700/XT instead. The other boards still offer similar performance, but the TUF or Gigabyte Elite models only provide a solid base if you really need low noise levels and are willing to pay more. Avoid versions with a window unless you’re certain about your needs.

T
Teddy_bear202
Member
180
02-19-2019, 08:49 AM
#5
I had the same doubt back in july and went with 3700x due to the extra threads for future proof and a bit cheaper, which with the diference i invested in a 480GB ssd. No regrets to be fair, even not being a good cpu for OC (it does reach 4.3-4.4 in some cores during games, 4.2 max all core load), it doesnt make much of a diference since it performs amazing. Also, u have fast enough RAM to go with it. Thats my opinion as a 3700x owner, maybe wait for a feedback of someone with the i7? As a mobo i went with tomahawk due to BIOS flash button, but here it is a list of vrms and quality of all boards for am4 and ryzen 3000: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1...=639584818 . One thing, it runs a bit hot ( but i believe the 9700k also does), but the dark rock will be enough, just make sure to update the chipset and BIOS to the latest versions that fixes the voltage thing.
T
Teddy_bear202
02-19-2019, 08:49 AM #5

I had the same doubt back in july and went with 3700x due to the extra threads for future proof and a bit cheaper, which with the diference i invested in a 480GB ssd. No regrets to be fair, even not being a good cpu for OC (it does reach 4.3-4.4 in some cores during games, 4.2 max all core load), it doesnt make much of a diference since it performs amazing. Also, u have fast enough RAM to go with it. Thats my opinion as a 3700x owner, maybe wait for a feedback of someone with the i7? As a mobo i went with tomahawk due to BIOS flash button, but here it is a list of vrms and quality of all boards for am4 and ryzen 3000: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1...=639584818 . One thing, it runs a bit hot ( but i believe the 9700k also does), but the dark rock will be enough, just make sure to update the chipset and BIOS to the latest versions that fixes the voltage thing.

G
gurfin321
Junior Member
44
02-24-2019, 11:02 PM
#6
Hi, the system comes with 32GB RAM, four channels, and using dual-channel with 16GB provides extra performance. The listed memory is praised for strong overclocking capabilities, reaching around 4000MHz. You’d likely choose the R7 3700X for its multithreaded performance benefits. For graphics, it’s important to pick a card with CUDA cores since it supports my financial trading workload. The motherboard can be any model you prefer, based on personal choice and preferences. I’m mindful of noise levels and thermal limits, so I need cases that handle heat well. For your budget in Denmark around 600DKK (about $90), I’d favor a quiet case with plenty of fans if possible. Thanks for your feedback—I look forward to more details.
G
gurfin321
02-24-2019, 11:02 PM #6

Hi, the system comes with 32GB RAM, four channels, and using dual-channel with 16GB provides extra performance. The listed memory is praised for strong overclocking capabilities, reaching around 4000MHz. You’d likely choose the R7 3700X for its multithreaded performance benefits. For graphics, it’s important to pick a card with CUDA cores since it supports my financial trading workload. The motherboard can be any model you prefer, based on personal choice and preferences. I’m mindful of noise levels and thermal limits, so I need cases that handle heat well. For your budget in Denmark around 600DKK (about $90), I’d favor a quiet case with plenty of fans if possible. Thanks for your feedback—I look forward to more details.

R
Roccoboy8
Member
162
03-02-2019, 02:09 AM
#7
The Define R4/5/6 models offer slightly better airflow while remaining relatively quiet overall. For maximum silence, aim for the fewest fans possible and opt for large heatsinks suitable for high-end CPUs or GPUs. You might consider a used 1080ti if your software supports VRAM, especially with 11GB of memory. Unlike desktop Ryzen chips with quad-channel support, overclocking four sticks isn’t as challenging as two, so sticking with two 16GB sticks seems reasonable. You may need to consult an overclocking forum for additional details.
R
Roccoboy8
03-02-2019, 02:09 AM #7

The Define R4/5/6 models offer slightly better airflow while remaining relatively quiet overall. For maximum silence, aim for the fewest fans possible and opt for large heatsinks suitable for high-end CPUs or GPUs. You might consider a used 1080ti if your software supports VRAM, especially with 11GB of memory. Unlike desktop Ryzen chips with quad-channel support, overclocking four sticks isn’t as challenging as two, so sticking with two 16GB sticks seems reasonable. You may need to consult an overclocking forum for additional details.

K
KMunster
Member
75
03-02-2019, 03:12 AM
#8
Hi, thanks for sharing your thoughts. You mentioned only working with Ryzen 7 3700X, right? So you chose the B450? Or is there another model involved? Generally, I believe the X570 platform offers better long-term value, even though it might cost more initially. It’s worth considering if you’re looking ahead to future upgrades. Regarding your questions about VRM and newer platforms, those details are important for performance planning. As for aesthetics, I’m a bit of a style person—what kind of look are you aiming for? That will help me suggest the best options. Feel free to ask more or share your thoughts so I can better guide you.
K
KMunster
03-02-2019, 03:12 AM #8

Hi, thanks for sharing your thoughts. You mentioned only working with Ryzen 7 3700X, right? So you chose the B450? Or is there another model involved? Generally, I believe the X570 platform offers better long-term value, even though it might cost more initially. It’s worth considering if you’re looking ahead to future upgrades. Regarding your questions about VRM and newer platforms, those details are important for performance planning. As for aesthetics, I’m a bit of a style person—what kind of look are you aiming for? That will help me suggest the best options. Feel free to ask more or share your thoughts so I can better guide you.

T
Tango599
Member
165
03-05-2019, 05:03 AM
#9
Hi, Thanks for your input again, To summarize your input, so that i don't misunderstand anything. 1. Get a Define R4/5/6 instead of the Pure Base 500, which should not be with a window if that is the final choice. 2. I should maybe look at a used GTX 1080ti instead of the RTX 2070super. However, is it still worth it, if a used GTX 1080ti is the same cost if not more expensive than the RTX 2070 super here in Denmark. Yes the used PC market is broken overhere. 3. I should go dual-channel 16GB if choosing the Ryzen 7 3700X processor? and i will do further investigating in overclocking forums. I am looking forward to hearing from you.
T
Tango599
03-05-2019, 05:03 AM #9

Hi, Thanks for your input again, To summarize your input, so that i don't misunderstand anything. 1. Get a Define R4/5/6 instead of the Pure Base 500, which should not be with a window if that is the final choice. 2. I should maybe look at a used GTX 1080ti instead of the RTX 2070super. However, is it still worth it, if a used GTX 1080ti is the same cost if not more expensive than the RTX 2070 super here in Denmark. Yes the used PC market is broken overhere. 3. I should go dual-channel 16GB if choosing the Ryzen 7 3700X processor? and i will do further investigating in overclocking forums. I am looking forward to hearing from you.

K
216
03-05-2019, 08:37 AM
#10
This channel focuses on boosting performance in any situation. A new view will show louder sounds than the foam panels, while the base and R4/5/6 models include them.
K
Kawaiichan1776
03-05-2019, 08:37 AM #10

This channel focuses on boosting performance in any situation. A new view will show louder sounds than the foam panels, while the base and R4/5/6 models include them.

Pages (2): 1 2 Next