Hyper 212 evo vs Corsair H100i
Hyper 212 evo vs Corsair H100i
The Hyper 212 and h100i represent completely different types of devices in distinct performance levels.
1. The 212 is a budget cooler, focusing on affordability rather than high-end features. It shouldn't be compared to the H100i in any meaningful way.
2. Many believe water cooling is superior to air cooling, but this isn't accurate for CLCs. The Noctua NH-D15 is widely seen as the top air cooler, achieving 71°C in hightechlegion's tests (video 17:10), whereas the H100i reached 73°C. This suggests the difference is more than just a 2°C gap.
The Hyper 212 and h100i represent completely different types of devices in distinct performance categories.
1. These models are essentially budget options, with a focus on the middle term. You shouldn't expect them to match the capabilities of the H100i.
2. Many believe that water cooling offers superior results compared to air cooling. However, this is not accurate when discussing CLCs; the Noctua NH-D15 is widely considered the top air cooler today, achieving temperatures around 71°C in hightechlegion's tests (refer to the 17:10 point in the video below), whereas the H100i reached 73°C. This highlights how a small difference can be significant when aiming for such close matches.
3. The main consideration is cost:
Air Coolers
$25 - Hyper 212
$35 - Cryorig H7
$45 to $55 - various Scythe Coolers
$65 - Phanteks PH-TC14-PE
$85 - Noctua NH-D15
All-in-one water coolers
CLC style coolers rely on aluminum radiators. Since aluminum conducts heat much less efficiently than copper, they need extremely high fan speeds (which also makes them very noisy) to approach the performance of air coolers. In addition, they combine metals like aluminum and copper, which is generally unsuitable for water cooling.
https://martinsliquidlab.wordpress.com/2...-explored/
Therefore, I don’t have any CLCs in this list. In the realm of high-quality all-in-one water cooling, Swiftech leads the market, followed by EK, though the latter is significantly pricier. Other manufacturers have tried but haven’t yet produced something that stands out.
With a system budget of $1,000, you won’t find these options. A 2 x 120mm radiator from Swiftech, pre-assembled with pump and reservoir, costs around $140. Two such units would be about $150, and three 120mm units would be roughly $165.
JackNaylorPE:
The Hyper 212 and h100i represent quite distinct categories in performance levels.
1. The 212 is essentially a budget cooler, with the emphasis on the middle word. It shouldn't be expected to match the H100i in any capacity.
2. Many believe water cooling offers superior results compared to air cooling. However, when discussing CLCs, this is far from accurate. The Noctua NH-D15 is widely seen as the top air cooler today, achieving temperatures around 71°C in hightechlegion's tests (see the 17:10 segment in the video below), whereas the H100i hit 73°C. This suggests that a 2°C difference isn't negligible until you factor in the H100i's noise level.
3. The core consideration is cost:
Air Coolers
$25 - Hyper 212
$35 - Cryorig H7
$45 to $55 - various Scythe Coolers
$65 - Phanteks PH-TC14-PE
$85 - Noctua NH-D15
All-in-one water coolers
CLC type coolers rely on aluminum radiators. Because aluminum's heat transfer is much lower than copper, they demand extremely high fan speeds (which translates to significant noise). Beyond being noticeably louder than air coolers, they also combine dissimilar metals (aluminum radiator and copper block), which is generally unsuitable for water cooling.
According to this analysis, I don’t have any CLCs on this list. In the realm of premium all-in-one water cooling, Swiftech leads the market, followed by EK, though the latter is considerably pricier. Other manufacturers have experimented but haven’t yet delivered impressive results.
With a budget around $1,000 for a system, you’re unlikely to find a suitable option. A 2 x 120mm radiator from Swiftech, pre-assembled with pump and reservoir, costs about $140. Two such units total $280, three units $165.
Interesting feedback and thanks for the corrosion insights. In high-end PC builds, most users replace components every three years or less, making corrosion less critical overall. Exceptions exist, but they’re rare.
Your take on Swiftech products seems questionable when you compare them to other reviews—such as the H240-X2 versus Corsair’s H115i. The latter clearly outperformed the former, with over 4000 units sold versus only 12 for Swiftech, and reviews being mostly average.
You might dismiss the Swiftech claim as weak in their own product feedback, but if you analyze data carefully, the numbers point toward a strong performer among the group.