F5F Stay Refreshed Software PC Gaming Have you experienced any impact from AA?

Have you experienced any impact from AA?

Have you experienced any impact from AA?

Pages (3): Previous 1 2 3 Next
Q
Quietvenom
Member
193
11-28-2022, 10:51 PM
#11
I doubt you'd require aa on such a budget monitor. It seems like a smart choice to save money.
Q
Quietvenom
11-28-2022, 10:51 PM #11

I doubt you'd require aa on such a budget monitor. It seems like a smart choice to save money.

M
MinnyMoomy
Junior Member
1
11-30-2022, 06:04 AM
#12
This offer is fairly reasonable, but it varies based on the game engine used.
M
MinnyMoomy
11-30-2022, 06:04 AM #12

This offer is fairly reasonable, but it varies based on the game engine used.

T
tazzyty6
Junior Member
14
12-06-2022, 08:20 AM
#13
Without AA you might see some rough edges in certain titles, but the experience really depends on how much you can handle. I’d probably settle for something straightforward like SMAA or FXAA for most games. If you’re playing at 1440p, it’s likely your graphics card can manage it smoothly without noticeable lag.
T
tazzyty6
12-06-2022, 08:20 AM #13

Without AA you might see some rough edges in certain titles, but the experience really depends on how much you can handle. I’d probably settle for something straightforward like SMAA or FXAA for most games. If you’re playing at 1440p, it’s likely your graphics card can manage it smoothly without noticeable lag.

L
LaniBooster
Senior Member
344
12-07-2022, 07:16 AM
#14
L
LaniBooster
12-07-2022, 07:16 AM #14

D
Dwinky
Junior Member
7
12-08-2022, 08:25 AM
#15
I don’t think most people actually require pushing AA to its limits unless it’s for testing or stress scenarios. As I mentioned before, even at 1080p, there seems to be little value beyond SMAA or doubling the resolution. This likely becomes more relevant at 1440p on a 25-inch screen.
D
Dwinky
12-08-2022, 08:25 AM #15

I don’t think most people actually require pushing AA to its limits unless it’s for testing or stress scenarios. As I mentioned before, even at 1080p, there seems to be little value beyond SMAA or doubling the resolution. This likely becomes more relevant at 1440p on a 25-inch screen.

W
W_O_L_F_R_A_M
Member
125
12-08-2022, 05:15 PM
#16
I'm a big fan of anti-aliasing techniques and even with 8X MSAA, I still saw some jagged edges on my old 1920x1080 23" screen. Usually I push the limits of anti-aliasing and try DSR to run games at higher resolutions if possible. Honestly, I prefer playing at 30fps rather than having a pixelated look. No exaggeration—I've noticed that as resolution and pixel density increase, aliasing becomes less obvious and I can comfortably lower the settings. Now that I have a display with 110ppi, it's much easier to use simpler methods like SMAA or just 4X MSAA. Still, I can't live without some form of anti-aliasing. Here are my thoughts on different approaches:

- SSAA is nearly perfect but may lose fine details when scaling down.
- MSAA doubles the previous method but isn't flawless and uses a lot of resources.
- 4x MSAA works for tough games but shows noticeable artifacts, especially with distant objects.
- SMAA offers good value and is often the best choice when supported.
- TXAA hasn’t improved my experience much.
- SMAA is probably the most practical option for most games.
- FXAA is ineffective—it just adds blur instead of fixing aliasing.
- DSR keeps sharp details better than SSAA and pairs well with cheaper methods.
- 4K DSR with 8X MSAA delivers top-tier results.
- 4K DSR with SMAA gives excellent quality.
- 4K DSR without any other AA is ideal for most scenarios.
W
W_O_L_F_R_A_M
12-08-2022, 05:15 PM #16

I'm a big fan of anti-aliasing techniques and even with 8X MSAA, I still saw some jagged edges on my old 1920x1080 23" screen. Usually I push the limits of anti-aliasing and try DSR to run games at higher resolutions if possible. Honestly, I prefer playing at 30fps rather than having a pixelated look. No exaggeration—I've noticed that as resolution and pixel density increase, aliasing becomes less obvious and I can comfortably lower the settings. Now that I have a display with 110ppi, it's much easier to use simpler methods like SMAA or just 4X MSAA. Still, I can't live without some form of anti-aliasing. Here are my thoughts on different approaches:

- SSAA is nearly perfect but may lose fine details when scaling down.
- MSAA doubles the previous method but isn't flawless and uses a lot of resources.
- 4x MSAA works for tough games but shows noticeable artifacts, especially with distant objects.
- SMAA offers good value and is often the best choice when supported.
- TXAA hasn’t improved my experience much.
- SMAA is probably the most practical option for most games.
- FXAA is ineffective—it just adds blur instead of fixing aliasing.
- DSR keeps sharp details better than SSAA and pairs well with cheaper methods.
- 4K DSR with 8X MSAA delivers top-tier results.
- 4K DSR with SMAA gives excellent quality.
- 4K DSR without any other AA is ideal for most scenarios.

N
NinaVanSteijn
Junior Member
44
12-08-2022, 05:52 PM
#17
It matters a bit, but it feels a bit average during gameplay. At 1080p four times the resolution works fine, and at even higher settings, AA isn't essential unless you're aiming for professional screenshots.
N
NinaVanSteijn
12-08-2022, 05:52 PM #17

It matters a bit, but it feels a bit average during gameplay. At 1080p four times the resolution works fine, and at even higher settings, AA isn't essential unless you're aiming for professional screenshots.

V
ValTheBG
Member
56
12-08-2022, 07:26 PM
#18
At 1080p I see a significant variation compared to lower settings, which is something I frequently experience while playing most of the time. In ultra settings I often disable AA because it becomes too taxing. Although I observe a contrast, it doesn’t really matter to me.
V
ValTheBG
12-08-2022, 07:26 PM #18

At 1080p I see a significant variation compared to lower settings, which is something I frequently experience while playing most of the time. In ultra settings I often disable AA because it becomes too taxing. Although I observe a contrast, it doesn’t really matter to me.

A
Athame_
Senior Member
734
12-10-2022, 04:21 AM
#19
Why? Between 4 samples and 8 you're getting such a slight difference in overall colour it's not going to affect the image much beyond a placebo. Any AA also blurs particle effects so there will be fidelity loss with any AA on to varying amounts depending on the type. If jaggies bother you that much then you need higher resolution and higher DPI, not AA. At 4K I can slightly notice the difference between off and 2x MSAA, but not enough to particularly care. I think 6K will probably be the stage of there being literally no difference at 28".
A
Athame_
12-10-2022, 04:21 AM #19

Why? Between 4 samples and 8 you're getting such a slight difference in overall colour it's not going to affect the image much beyond a placebo. Any AA also blurs particle effects so there will be fidelity loss with any AA on to varying amounts depending on the type. If jaggies bother you that much then you need higher resolution and higher DPI, not AA. At 4K I can slightly notice the difference between off and 2x MSAA, but not enough to particularly care. I think 6K will probably be the stage of there being literally no difference at 28".

F
FionnMacu
Member
147
12-10-2022, 04:29 AM
#20
The distinction is clear, right? I rely on it whenever possible, even with the added processing cost, but my GTX670 is beginning to lag, so I avoid it in newer titles.
F
FionnMacu
12-10-2022, 04:29 AM #20

The distinction is clear, right? I rely on it whenever possible, even with the added processing cost, but my GTX670 is beginning to lag, so I avoid it in newer titles.

Pages (3): Previous 1 2 3 Next