F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Guidelines for ECC RAM with X470 motherboards

Guidelines for ECC RAM with X470 motherboards

Guidelines for ECC RAM with X470 motherboards

B
ben_dragon
Senior Member
259
03-10-2018, 06:52 PM
#1
Hello everyone, I'm setting up a home lab/NAS server and have acquired an X470 board along with a Ryzen 7 at a budget-friendly price. The MSI site says it works with ECC memory. I'm curious if anyone has tips on using registered memory with this board—should I avoid old ECC dimm and rely only on the modules listed on the compatibility page, or should I opt for standard parts for my server? Here are the board details: MSI X470 Gaming Plus specs link: https://www.msi.com/Motherboard/X470-GAM...cification compatibility list link: https://www.msi.com/Motherboard/X470-GAM...upport#mem. Any suggestions for running a home server would be great. So far I'm using Proxmox with a VM for Truenas, an Ubuntu server, and a Docker/Portainer container. I just need more RAM and storage to finish the build.
B
ben_dragon
03-10-2018, 06:52 PM #1

Hello everyone, I'm setting up a home lab/NAS server and have acquired an X470 board along with a Ryzen 7 at a budget-friendly price. The MSI site says it works with ECC memory. I'm curious if anyone has tips on using registered memory with this board—should I avoid old ECC dimm and rely only on the modules listed on the compatibility page, or should I opt for standard parts for my server? Here are the board details: MSI X470 Gaming Plus specs link: https://www.msi.com/Motherboard/X470-GAM...cification compatibility list link: https://www.msi.com/Motherboard/X470-GAM...upport#mem. Any suggestions for running a home server would be great. So far I'm using Proxmox with a VM for Truenas, an Ubuntu server, and a Docker/Portainer container. I just need more RAM and storage to finish the build.

S
SenpaiAllen
Junior Member
48
03-10-2018, 08:29 PM
#2
Yes, this board supports ECC, though it needs the pricier, less common unbuffered version. If you can afford it, go with that; otherwise, stick to regular, non-ECC, unbuffered DIMMs.
S
SenpaiAllen
03-10-2018, 08:29 PM #2

Yes, this board supports ECC, though it needs the pricier, less common unbuffered version. If you can afford it, go with that; otherwise, stick to regular, non-ECC, unbuffered DIMMs.

K
Kyrociz
Junior Member
15
03-10-2018, 09:48 PM
#3
Registered modules aren't functioning properly. The memory controller is built into the CPU, and AM4 processors from Ryzen support only standard (unbuffered) DDR4 and regular ECC DDR4. Motherboards with AM4 sockets don't accept FB or LRDIMM DDR4 modules. The amount of ECC supported varies by motherboard and BIOS.
K
Kyrociz
03-10-2018, 09:48 PM #3

Registered modules aren't functioning properly. The memory controller is built into the CPU, and AM4 processors from Ryzen support only standard (unbuffered) DDR4 and regular ECC DDR4. Motherboards with AM4 sockets don't accept FB or LRDIMM DDR4 modules. The amount of ECC supported varies by motherboard and BIOS.