F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop Consider other options besides PFSense for gaming needs.

Consider other options besides PFSense for gaming needs.

Consider other options besides PFSense for gaming needs.

W
Wu_xj
Junior Member
40
04-07-2023, 10:17 PM
#1
Hey there, I'm currently using PFSense as my home router. I really appreciate what it offers—great features and the ability to separate my network from certain services. The main issue I'm facing is that I and my brother can't play games together simultaneously. Recently, we tried BO3 with a friend, but both had strict NAT settings. After some research on YouTube and Reddit, I found a solution that lets one computer have a moderate NAT. However, once my brother logged in, I lost access to the online services. It seems the problem was port conflicts. Now I'm looking for an alternative to PFSense that still supports segmentation and VLANs without the UPnP and gaming headaches. I've been considering the Ubiquiti Edgerouter X, but I'd love some advice on software options since I already have a hardware setup I like. Any suggestions would be great, or if you've had success with PFSense, I'm open to helping fix it. Thanks!
W
Wu_xj
04-07-2023, 10:17 PM #1

Hey there, I'm currently using PFSense as my home router. I really appreciate what it offers—great features and the ability to separate my network from certain services. The main issue I'm facing is that I and my brother can't play games together simultaneously. Recently, we tried BO3 with a friend, but both had strict NAT settings. After some research on YouTube and Reddit, I found a solution that lets one computer have a moderate NAT. However, once my brother logged in, I lost access to the online services. It seems the problem was port conflicts. Now I'm looking for an alternative to PFSense that still supports segmentation and VLANs without the UPnP and gaming headaches. I've been considering the Ubiquiti Edgerouter X, but I'd love some advice on software options since I already have a hardware setup I like. Any suggestions would be great, or if you've had success with PFSense, I'm open to helping fix it. Thanks!

Z
Zakko181103
Member
53
04-07-2023, 11:29 PM
#2
Clients typically choose a random port for outgoing links, and servers should manage many clients connecting without issues. It seems their system may dislike connections originating from the same public IP. Do you use individual accounts or a shared one?
Z
Zakko181103
04-07-2023, 11:29 PM #2

Clients typically choose a random port for outgoing links, and servers should manage many clients connecting without issues. It seems their system may dislike connections originating from the same public IP. Do you use individual accounts or a shared one?

J
jamie2k
Member
51
04-08-2023, 01:03 AM
#3
Is the current pfSense release stable? There was an issue with uPNP when several devices attempted to share ports, but it seems the problem has been resolved.
J
jamie2k
04-08-2023, 01:03 AM #3

Is the current pfSense release stable? There was an issue with uPNP when several devices attempted to share ports, but it seems the problem has been resolved.

M
manband181
Member
59
04-08-2023, 06:14 AM
#4
We each had our own accounts. Around six months ago, before installing the new router, everything worked fine and the game played smoothly. Open NAT and all that.
M
manband181
04-08-2023, 06:14 AM #4

We each had our own accounts. Around six months ago, before installing the new router, everything worked fine and the game played smoothly. Open NAT and all that.

X
xXxArsenalxXx
Member
62
04-21-2023, 11:58 AM
#5
Your current version is 2.6.0, and I'll check if this is the one associated with the issue you're experiencing.
X
xXxArsenalxXx
04-21-2023, 11:58 AM #5

Your current version is 2.6.0, and I'll check if this is the one associated with the issue you're experiencing.

P
Pimousse62620
Member
234
04-23-2023, 02:54 AM
#6
I agree, it was the 2.7.0 update mentioned in the changelog that addressed the issue.
P
Pimousse62620
04-23-2023, 02:54 AM #6

I agree, it was the 2.7.0 update mentioned in the changelog that addressed the issue.

D
Dragonxd07
Member
112
04-23-2023, 04:14 AM
#7
I haven't used it before, though I've heard some suggest it's not free anymore. Others have recommended it despite that.
D
Dragonxd07
04-23-2023, 04:14 AM #7

I haven't used it before, though I've heard some suggest it's not free anymore. Others have recommended it despite that.

F
Fokeiiz
Member
191
04-23-2023, 10:01 AM
#8
I don’t want to move away from pfSense since it meets all my requirements. I tried OpenWRT before, and after the switch it performed better—pages loaded quicker and I could configure more advanced network settings.
F
Fokeiiz
04-23-2023, 10:01 AM #8

I don’t want to move away from pfSense since it meets all my requirements. I tried OpenWRT before, and after the switch it performed better—pages loaded quicker and I could configure more advanced network settings.