Choose between STP(CAT6) and coaxial cable based on your needs.
Choose between STP(CAT6) and coaxial cable based on your needs.
Hello, Your ISP has set up your internet via a coax cable and provided a modem with an Ethernet port. You're considering replacing the modem with a STP connection and directly connecting the Ethernet jack to your router. Your setup includes many mobile devices and a few laptops, and you plan to eventually host a server for file access. Are you thinking about switching from coax/modem to fiber? You mentioned coax reduces noise compared to STP wires—would that be a good idea? Also, are there any reliability concerns with STP during storms or other weather events? Regarding the distance, your current 25-meter cable length seems sufficient for most needs.
You need the modem. The setup isn’t that simple—just because you don’t like something doesn’t mean you should skip it. Your router won’t work if the coax signal isn’t properly handled. The modem converts the signal so the router can understand it. If the ISP changes to STP, they’ll still install a modem, but you won’t be able to use it afterward.
Would that really cause an issue? If so, I won’t need to connect a device that heats up a lot and has a tricky AC-DC port. That’s the approach I’m considering—I’m not certain about the downsides.
I believe they could easily do it. I saw it happen in two of my friends' homes. Do you really need to connect to the modem? Right now I lack any setup permissions besides being able to reach it physically. I was concerned about how the two providers—Coax and CAT6—would compare in terms of lasting quality and noise levels. Since I’m in a tropical area with frequent thunderstorms and heavy rain, that’s something to think about.
It isn't anything like that. Since the appartments are old, they don't have any network wiring, neither coax nor CAT6. The ISP just puts in a cable from the nearest box , which is visible at all times and they connect their router to it. If you remember how old telephone posts used to work. So, if there is a modem, either I have to keep it in my home or the ISP can connect it to their post.
I think that's incorrect. ISPs using coax typically operate between 5 MHz and 1 GHz for TV and internet. You also find other services in those frequency ranges, like broadcast TV and cellular networks. If your coax cable or connector fails, you'll likely experience significant interference. I’ve personally noticed some interference affecting my internet through the coax connection. You can look up potential issues on your modem’s manual pages if you have access. Also, if your internet comes via coax, you’re probably connected to a cable or fiber provider. With a cable provider, the modem needs to be fully functional. If it’s a fiber provider, Ethernet should work fine. If your modem requires a reboot, you might need to contact the ISP each time instead of unplugging it. In my area, most utilities operate wirelessly, so they can’t install equipment in places with underground lines.
Thank you for your message. The issue is that I can't reach my modem, and I'm unsure if purchasing another one would be feasible since my operator isn't responding clearly. It seems my provider is likely a cable company. Unfortunately, my ISP works with multiple network providers, and I don't know if switching to a fiber service in my area would make financial sense. The main concern is that I can't access my modem, and because the Ethernet cable is small, I must place it near my router. This forces me to keep both devices in an area with two power outlets, as their power connectors are too large for a three-pin socket.
Consider purchasing a longer Ethernet cable—this part is easily replaceable.