F5F Stay Refreshed Software Operating Systems Removing "Annoying" Windows 10 features violates the DMCA, according to Microsoft.

Removing "Annoying" Windows 10 features violates the DMCA, according to Microsoft.

Removing "Annoying" Windows 10 features violates the DMCA, according to Microsoft.

X
xXZommerXx
Member
77
07-16-2016, 03:22 AM
#1
The author argues that removing features from Windows 10 may violate the DMCA. Microsoft is accused of overreaching, and concerns grow about future actions targeting lightweight or alternative OS versions.
X
xXZommerXx
07-16-2016, 03:22 AM #1

The author argues that removing features from Windows 10 may violate the DMCA. Microsoft is accused of overreaching, and concerns grow about future actions targeting lightweight or alternative OS versions.

D
DiegoLeCreep
Member
88
08-03-2016, 01:13 AM
#2
Am I to understand that this isn't just a tool you install, but a modded version of Windows? If so, releasing it to the public IS a DMCA violation, as you do not own the code to Windows (apparently the ISO is like, 17GB). There's a difference between modding your own OS with some tools and the act of providing the already modded OS out for all to use. Even more so if it's a pirated version of Windows. Not sure why they decided to ban hammer it down based on the "removal of features" though...
D
DiegoLeCreep
08-03-2016, 01:13 AM #2

Am I to understand that this isn't just a tool you install, but a modded version of Windows? If so, releasing it to the public IS a DMCA violation, as you do not own the code to Windows (apparently the ISO is like, 17GB). There's a difference between modding your own OS with some tools and the act of providing the already modded OS out for all to use. Even more so if it's a pirated version of Windows. Not sure why they decided to ban hammer it down based on the "removal of features" though...

K
KeeversoonBr
Junior Member
44
08-03-2016, 06:27 PM
#3
Another valid reason to switch to Linux. Just a joke. 😄
K
KeeversoonBr
08-03-2016, 06:27 PM #3

Another valid reason to switch to Linux. Just a joke. 😄

S
Spidercyber
Senior Member
673
08-04-2016, 12:42 AM
#4
Eh, yes but. The only way to actually remove the spyware from Windows 10 *is* to release a recompiled version that doesn't have the stuff built in. Not all of that stuff can be removed during runtime because Windows is specifically designed to prevent modification of certain areas and that design actually does work (most of the time). So this isn't as clear cut as M$ lawyers might want it to be. Now, once you get into Voir Dire for the case, if you even give them a whiff that you understand that you'll be taken out of the jury pool. But still, it's simple logic. If a company makes it so that they get to spy on you no matter what, and you say no, that *isn't* a copyright violation. That's a privacy violation. The fact that the company made it so that they also had to commit a copyright violation to fix the privacy violation is an entirely different matter.
S
Spidercyber
08-04-2016, 12:42 AM #4

Eh, yes but. The only way to actually remove the spyware from Windows 10 *is* to release a recompiled version that doesn't have the stuff built in. Not all of that stuff can be removed during runtime because Windows is specifically designed to prevent modification of certain areas and that design actually does work (most of the time). So this isn't as clear cut as M$ lawyers might want it to be. Now, once you get into Voir Dire for the case, if you even give them a whiff that you understand that you'll be taken out of the jury pool. But still, it's simple logic. If a company makes it so that they get to spy on you no matter what, and you say no, that *isn't* a copyright violation. That's a privacy violation. The fact that the company made it so that they also had to commit a copyright violation to fix the privacy violation is an entirely different matter.

W
Wizwek
Junior Member
21
08-04-2016, 07:12 AM
#5
It's accurate if Ninjutsu OS incorporates Microsoft's software; this would definitely breach the DMCA.
W
Wizwek
08-04-2016, 07:12 AM #5

It's accurate if Ninjutsu OS incorporates Microsoft's software; this would definitely breach the DMCA.

P
Papyrule
Senior Member
560
08-04-2016, 06:07 PM
#6
The final statement reminds you a license is required... (Also, W10 should function without a key for a long time unless changed, as per someone I know.)
P
Papyrule
08-04-2016, 06:07 PM #6

The final statement reminds you a license is required... (Also, W10 should function without a key for a long time unless changed, as per someone I know.)