F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks Positioning the router within your residence's network area

Positioning the router within your residence's network area

Positioning the router within your residence's network area

E
ELQ_gamer
Junior Member
10
03-17-2023, 03:47 AM
#1
Previously I used a standard gigabit router with four ports and an unmanaged 5-port network switch. Now I own a 24-port HP managed switch and am figuring out the best wiring setup. I'm weighing direct connections between my main computers and the router versus routing them through the switch. While a direct link to the internet sounds simpler, it won't significantly impact traffic through the switch. Linking everything via the switch generally improves overall network performance, particularly for my storage server, since the HP switch handles more capacity than my router does. Would it make sense to connect some devices straight to the router instead of using the switch?
E
ELQ_gamer
03-17-2023, 03:47 AM #1

Previously I used a standard gigabit router with four ports and an unmanaged 5-port network switch. Now I own a 24-port HP managed switch and am figuring out the best wiring setup. I'm weighing direct connections between my main computers and the router versus routing them through the switch. While a direct link to the internet sounds simpler, it won't significantly impact traffic through the switch. Linking everything via the switch generally improves overall network performance, particularly for my storage server, since the HP switch handles more capacity than my router does. Would it make sense to connect some devices straight to the router instead of using the switch?

K
KingSloth
Member
61
03-22-2023, 07:00 PM
#2
Offering higher throughput per device would be a significant advantage. Your switch doesn't seem to have any port limitations either.
K
KingSloth
03-22-2023, 07:00 PM #2

Offering higher throughput per device would be a significant advantage. Your switch doesn't seem to have any port limitations either.

M
Metal_Blox
Member
57
03-23-2023, 09:16 AM
#3
In most cases, there aren't many options to consider. The main idea seems to be setting up the LA connection between the router and another device. This task can also be handled via the switch.
M
Metal_Blox
03-23-2023, 09:16 AM #3

In most cases, there aren't many options to consider. The main idea seems to be setting up the LA connection between the router and another device. This task can also be handled via the switch.

A
ArceusHD
Member
154
03-23-2023, 10:44 AM
#4
Simply connect everything to the switch. I only change other devices to their own IP ranges using DHCP if I need separate networks for testing or development.
A
ArceusHD
03-23-2023, 10:44 AM #4

Simply connect everything to the switch. I only change other devices to their own IP ranges using DHCP if I need separate networks for testing or development.

F
F21raptor
Junior Member
18
03-25-2023, 05:07 AM
#5
Sure, happy to help. Just need those two-foot network cables and the Noctua 40 mm fan. The regular one tends to be too loud.
F
F21raptor
03-25-2023, 05:07 AM #5

Sure, happy to help. Just need those two-foot network cables and the Noctua 40 mm fan. The regular one tends to be too loud.

B
Behaved
Junior Member
2
03-25-2023, 06:50 AM
#6
I think it's better to have the DHCP server built into the router itself. I question whether the switch will even support DHCP properly.
B
Behaved
03-25-2023, 06:50 AM #6

I think it's better to have the DHCP server built into the router itself. I question whether the switch will even support DHCP properly.

B
bushminecraft
Member
189
03-25-2023, 10:43 AM
#7
It's not possible, which suggests you should configure VLANs (if your router allows) or connect directly for extra subnets. For my setup, I rely on VLANs for stable subnets, but during testing it's simpler to connect straight to the router and remove it afterward.
B
bushminecraft
03-25-2023, 10:43 AM #7

It's not possible, which suggests you should configure VLANs (if your router allows) or connect directly for extra subnets. For my setup, I rely on VLANs for stable subnets, but during testing it's simpler to connect straight to the router and remove it afterward.

M
May_V2
Junior Member
40
03-27-2023, 08:33 AM
#8
You have a simple home router from TP-Link with an AC1750 port, which means it lacks VLAN capabilities but still offers enterprise-grade Wi-Fi security.
M
May_V2
03-27-2023, 08:33 AM #8

You have a simple home router from TP-Link with an AC1750 port, which means it lacks VLAN capabilities but still offers enterprise-grade Wi-Fi security.