F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks Issues with network switches

Issues with network switches

Issues with network switches

S
strandofgrass
Member
52
04-29-2023, 04:35 AM
#1
I am planning to start up a really very small server at home which is just a nano-itx board and some hard disks. The problems I am facing is: 1. Can I just connect the "server" to an unmanaged switch which cannot be configured or I need a manageable switch and port forward my server? 2. My ISP gives me dynamic IP, can I host VPN server, mail server, etc? 3. If I really need a manageable switch, please suggest some which are not expensive and space saving (I don't need those with 24 ports, just 4 to 8 is enough). Thanks a lot for reading this, please help me!!!
S
strandofgrass
04-29-2023, 04:35 AM #1

I am planning to start up a really very small server at home which is just a nano-itx board and some hard disks. The problems I am facing is: 1. Can I just connect the "server" to an unmanaged switch which cannot be configured or I need a manageable switch and port forward my server? 2. My ISP gives me dynamic IP, can I host VPN server, mail server, etc? 3. If I really need a manageable switch, please suggest some which are not expensive and space saving (I don't need those with 24 ports, just 4 to 8 is enough). Thanks a lot for reading this, please help me!!!

T
Tarzan22
Junior Member
15
04-30-2023, 08:32 PM
#2
No need for a managed switch. Route traffic through the router directly, not via the switch. Hosting is possible but you must forward the correct ports to the server's internal address.
T
Tarzan22
04-30-2023, 08:32 PM #2

No need for a managed switch. Route traffic through the router directly, not via the switch. Hosting is possible but you must forward the correct ports to the server's internal address.

Y
youtubexp234
Junior Member
45
05-02-2023, 06:50 PM
#3
This is what I came up with.
Y
youtubexp234
05-02-2023, 06:50 PM #3

This is what I came up with.

G
Greytide
Member
159
05-02-2023, 07:40 PM
#4
This setup isn't working. You should reverse the switch and router positions and then link the server to the switch.
G
Greytide
05-02-2023, 07:40 PM #4

This setup isn't working. You should reverse the switch and router positions and then link the server to the switch.

T
ThatFNaFGamer
Member
139
05-24-2023, 12:11 PM
#5
Yes, if you stick with your plan, you'll likely require a managed switch.
T
ThatFNaFGamer
05-24-2023, 12:11 PM #5

Yes, if you stick with your plan, you'll likely require a managed switch.

M
minerboy3033
Member
51
05-25-2023, 12:18 AM
#6
If you require VLANs, obtain them. Otherwise, you won't need them.
M
minerboy3033
05-25-2023, 12:18 AM #6

If you require VLANs, obtain them. Otherwise, you won't need them.

M
mathmaster99
Junior Member
16
05-25-2023, 01:39 AM
#7
You should not place a switch between the router and ISP connection. The ISP assigns an IP address, which is the initial point of contact, and once that’s set, the rest of your network won’t have access. Follow this order: ISP → Router → Switch → everything else.
M
mathmaster99
05-25-2023, 01:39 AM #7

You should not place a switch between the router and ISP connection. The ISP assigns an IP address, which is the initial point of contact, and once that’s set, the rest of your network won’t have access. Follow this order: ISP → Router → Switch → everything else.

R
Rey_Gordo6
Member
51
05-26-2023, 07:00 PM
#8
Everyone has mentioned the same thing: an ISP provides only one IP address to your home network, which is tied to your router. Purchasing a managed switch won’t change that. You should link your unmanaged switch to the router first, then connect all internet-dependent devices to it. For server ports, open them on your router instead. Your ISP will likely assign you a dynamic IP—changing whenever they decide, often when your router restarts—which defeats the purpose of running a server. You’ll need a service that gives you a static IP so it can forward the dynamic one. I personally use Dynu, but many other options exist. Happy serving!
R
Rey_Gordo6
05-26-2023, 07:00 PM #8

Everyone has mentioned the same thing: an ISP provides only one IP address to your home network, which is tied to your router. Purchasing a managed switch won’t change that. You should link your unmanaged switch to the router first, then connect all internet-dependent devices to it. For server ports, open them on your router instead. Your ISP will likely assign you a dynamic IP—changing whenever they decide, often when your router restarts—which defeats the purpose of running a server. You’ll need a service that gives you a static IP so it can forward the dynamic one. I personally use Dynu, but many other options exist. Happy serving!