F5F Stay Refreshed Hardware Desktop DDR4 RDIMMs compatible with DDR4 Z790 boards

DDR4 RDIMMs compatible with DDR4 Z790 boards

DDR4 RDIMMs compatible with DDR4 Z790 boards

Pages (2): 1 2 Next
T
thetalkkari
Member
152
08-28-2022, 10:57 AM
#1
Quick question. I've never worked with DDR4 memory before. A 16GB PC4-3200 RDIMM that came from a server upgrade ended up in my hands, and I tried it on my desktop for some jokes. It didn't boot up, even after resetting the CMOS. The board lights suggested it wasn't recognizing the memory. I thought RDIMMs should have different keying, but they fit the slot. Do any Z790 or LGA1700 boards support RDIMMs? My board is an MSI Z790 Tomahawk Wi-Fi DDR4.
T
thetalkkari
08-28-2022, 10:57 AM #1

Quick question. I've never worked with DDR4 memory before. A 16GB PC4-3200 RDIMM that came from a server upgrade ended up in my hands, and I tried it on my desktop for some jokes. It didn't boot up, even after resetting the CMOS. The board lights suggested it wasn't recognizing the memory. I thought RDIMMs should have different keying, but they fit the slot. Do any Z790 or LGA1700 boards support RDIMMs? My board is an MSI Z790 Tomahawk Wi-Fi DDR4.

G
Gilad2004
Junior Member
32
08-31-2022, 02:41 PM
#2
It seems compatible mainly with uncompressed/registered EEC RAM. *unbuffered/ unregistered*
G
Gilad2004
08-31-2022, 02:41 PM #2

It seems compatible mainly with uncompressed/registered EEC RAM. *unbuffered/ unregistered*

I
ikesperandio
Junior Member
17
08-31-2022, 03:43 PM
#3
I made a move. That would've been great. It could have been a valuable bonus.
I
ikesperandio
08-31-2022, 03:43 PM #3

I made a move. That would've been great. It could have been a valuable bonus.

H
Hunter1202005
Member
133
08-31-2022, 05:47 PM
#4
According to my understanding, RDIMMs generally need a memory controller tailored for them, and standard LGA 1700 CPUs lack these enhancements. You can work with unregistered ECC memory on W680 boards, though registered DIMMs aren't supported.
H
Hunter1202005
08-31-2022, 05:47 PM #4

According to my understanding, RDIMMs generally need a memory controller tailored for them, and standard LGA 1700 CPUs lack these enhancements. You can work with unregistered ECC memory on W680 boards, though registered DIMMs aren't supported.

L
lizzard89
Senior Member
707
09-13-2022, 07:23 PM
#5
RDIMMs are compatible exclusively with Xeon, Epyc and Threadrippers. For the DDR5 generation, these components now only support RDIMMs—though EPYC models on AM5 still have limited options (those ECC variants work). Consumer devices generally require UDIMMs or ECC, not RDIMMs.
L
lizzard89
09-13-2022, 07:23 PM #5

RDIMMs are compatible exclusively with Xeon, Epyc and Threadrippers. For the DDR5 generation, these components now only support RDIMMs—though EPYC models on AM5 still have limited options (those ECC variants work). Consumer devices generally require UDIMMs or ECC, not RDIMMs.

V
VinLark
Member
74
10-02-2022, 07:39 AM
#6
They contain a dedicated chip to handle tasks, allowing smoother operation with multiple RAM modules. Though adding more RAM can seem impressive, it rarely boosts gaming performance and is generally not recommended for gaming purposes.
V
VinLark
10-02-2022, 07:39 AM #6

They contain a dedicated chip to handle tasks, allowing smoother operation with multiple RAM modules. Though adding more RAM can seem impressive, it rarely boosts gaming performance and is generally not recommended for gaming purposes.

Y
yuta
Junior Member
3
10-02-2022, 05:49 PM
#7
The chip manages the address lines, reducing the load on the memory controller when handling many chips. This matters for servers because they usually have more memory and support additional chips, along with wider signal distribution. During the upgrade I added 1TB of DDR4 across all four CPUs in that server. Not everyone prioritizes performance; some focus on getting free components to build a computer.
Y
yuta
10-02-2022, 05:49 PM #7

The chip manages the address lines, reducing the load on the memory controller when handling many chips. This matters for servers because they usually have more memory and support additional chips, along with wider signal distribution. During the upgrade I added 1TB of DDR4 across all four CPUs in that server. Not everyone prioritizes performance; some focus on getting free components to build a computer.

L
LolaLouie
Senior Member
742
10-02-2022, 06:43 PM
#8
Absolutely, I use unregistered ECC memory on my TrueNAS server at home.
L
LolaLouie
10-02-2022, 06:43 PM #8

Absolutely, I use unregistered ECC memory on my TrueNAS server at home.

D
de3gutter
Junior Member
43
10-16-2022, 06:07 PM
#9
Apologies - I thought this was about a gaming system upgrade. However, the answer is clearer: No... But! I've noticed motherboards on Aliexpress that support RDIMMs, which are designed on platforms not originally intended for ECC or RDIMMs. If you're really determined, you might explore those options. Thanks for the guidance!
D
de3gutter
10-16-2022, 06:07 PM #9

Apologies - I thought this was about a gaming system upgrade. However, the answer is clearer: No... But! I've noticed motherboards on Aliexpress that support RDIMMs, which are designed on platforms not originally intended for ECC or RDIMMs. If you're really determined, you might explore those options. Thanks for the guidance!

H
HellNether
Senior Member
731
10-16-2022, 07:04 PM
#10
These boards use outdated server chip designs originally intended for rdimms.
H
HellNether
10-16-2022, 07:04 PM #10

These boards use outdated server chip designs originally intended for rdimms.

Pages (2): 1 2 Next