Comparison between ASUS TUF FX506 and HP VICTUS 16
Comparison between ASUS TUF FX506 and HP VICTUS 16
Hello,
I am looking for a laptop and discovered some options at a store in my country with Black Friday deals.
The Asus Tuf Fx506 features an Intel i5 10300h, GTX 1650, 8GB RAM, 512GB NVMe SSD, 15.6-inch IPS display at 144Hz, and 48Wh battery, priced at 650€ (originally 800€).
The HP Victus 16 with Ryzen 5 5600H, GTX 1650, 8GB RAM, 512GB NVMe SSD, 16.1-inch IPS at 144Hz, and 70Wh battery is also available, costing 650€ (originally 950€).
I visited the store and asked the sales assistant for a comparison. He mentioned that the HP Victus offers a better CPU (equivalent to the 5600H being an 11th Gen Intel i5), a larger screen, improved chassis, superior build quality, and better cooling.
I’d like to hear your thoughts on the value of these two models, especially regarding their build quality, cooling performance, and which one you think is more suitable.
Previously, I preferred the Asus Tuf for its gaming aesthetic, RGB keyboard, and brand reputation, but the sales assistant suggested the HP Victus is superior and noted it was priced about 150€ higher.
Additionally, does the HP have a longer battery life?
Thank you in advance for your advice. I’d appreciate a recommendation before Friday, when I need to finalize my purchase to take advantage of the discounts.
Appreciate your time and I’m sorry for any errors in grammar or vocabulary.
Sure, let's talk about the Ryzen setup. It offers a quicker CPU, improved efficiency, lower temperatures, and more screen space along with a longer battery life. I’d use it every day and even on Sundays!
But the GPU quality is still quite basic at this point. For better performance, a machine with at least a 3050ti would be ideal.
With only 8GB of RAM, you’re already limited for gaming right out of the box. You’d probably have to pay extra for a 16GB model. Otherwise, you’ll likely notice lag in games and slow system responsiveness. That’s because it’s running at 8GB in single-channel mode—really not ideal.
If I were you, I’d opt for 16GB RAM, a 3050ti minimum, and a 512GB SSD would work well. The Ryzen remains the better CPU choice between these options.
Hello!
Your reply is really appreciated!
I understand your point about the Ryzen model being a strong choice.
I know the GTX 1650 isn’t a powerful GPU, but my laptop budget is tight and most other models I’ve seen at around 650€ or less have integrated graphics. For RTX 3050ti or 3060, prices start near 900€, which makes me think it’s better to stick with the budget laptop. I plan to play a bit and mostly use it for studying, but I still want a machine with its own GPU.
I’d like to ask if you have any insights on comparing the Asus Tuf and HP Victus in terms of build quality and cooling. Any thoughts would be great!
Thanks again for your assistance, and I look forward to your response on this topic.
Best regards,
Ioannis V.
Hey Ionnis,
No probs mate, you're very welcome!
In light of what you've said, then either will be good enough. But I'd still go for the Victus with the Ryzen.
There aren't many reviews of either, but here is some food for thought:
HP Victus 16 review: Affordable gaming laptop with AMD CPU and Nvidia GPU - NotebookCheck.net Reviews
- this one has a different GPU, but same chassis and remainder setup.
ASUS TUF Gaming F15 (FX506) review - a decent performer that is easy on your budget | LaptopMedia.com
I have an Omen 15 2019 (I79750H +GTX1660ti). I do like the build quality of any of the HP machines I've had. I've never had issue with any of them. I've heard some bad things about the TUF laptops from time to time, but then they are also well considered in other reviews.
Cooling wise, HP are normally very good. Ill give my own example (as it's something I've researched extensively), with my Omen. They really do cool the proc very well. I hit about 80-85c when all cores are loaded at full pelt of 4ghz. It just stays steady, with no throttling.
Most gaming laptops get hot. But with a Ryzen cpu, and a HP cooling system, I can vouch for that. It works and works well.
For the TUF line, I can't be certain about their laptops as I've not had one, and the reviews are limited. With that said, I'm a huge ASUS fan. I have always gone with their mobos for my builds, have had GPU's from them, PSU's etc . They are a quality brand in general (IMO), so they don't make crap either.
Hope that helps guide you somewhat.
Hello once more,
I wanted to express my gratitude again for responding to my message the second time. Your assistance is truly appreciated.
The reviews you shared were very useful. From what I understand, the Hp screen quality surpasses the Asus in terms of sRGB coverage (99%) and brightness, making it a stronger option.
I identified only two minor points when comparing it to the TUF: first, the Victus features a white keyboard backlight whereas the TUF offers RGB lighting with nicely illuminated keys; second, the Victus screen tends to be more wobbly when touched, though I believe this can be managed. Additionally, the TUF appears more stable in the keyboard area compared to the Victus.
Overall, my main concerns revolve around the build quality and the perceived durability of the Victus versus the TUF. While it seems the Victus might have better technical specifications, I’d like to know your perspective on its robustness. If you have any insights or comparisons from friends, please share them—I’m open to hearing your thoughts.
Thank you once more for your support.
Kind regards,
Ioannis V.
Hey there,
The TUF is built to be extremely durable by design. It's intended for heavy-duty use (TUF - Tough), so it should have a very solid construction that can withstand minor impacts without getting damaged.
I'm not sure about the cooling system on the TUF, though.
For close decisions, I let the better hardware handle it.