F5F Stay Refreshed Software Operating Systems Compare Windows 10 and Windows 11 for top gaming performance.

Compare Windows 10 and Windows 11 for top gaming performance.

Compare Windows 10 and Windows 11 for top gaming performance.

B
Bananabut12
Member
64
01-24-2021, 10:30 PM
#1
Hey there, I'm still weighing whether to move my gaming PC to Windows 11 from Windows 10. I've got a Ryzen 9 5900X, a 3080TI, and plenty of storage options—HDDs, SATA SSDs, and NVMe drives. My monitor is the Samsung Odyssey G9. To be honest, I mainly run competitive and recent games on Windows, while using Linux for emulated and retro titles. My main concerns about upgrading are: getting direct storage access, the improved HDR display, avoiding crashes with DX12 games like Civilization VI, not being able to play Elden Ring properly, and the fact that some games freeze when I turn off HDR. On the other hand, I don't want to lose my current stability, enjoy smooth framerates, or get used to new settings. I'm trying to decide if a 30-day trial is enough to make the change. Any thoughts or experiences you've had would be really helpful!
B
Bananabut12
01-24-2021, 10:30 PM #1

Hey there, I'm still weighing whether to move my gaming PC to Windows 11 from Windows 10. I've got a Ryzen 9 5900X, a 3080TI, and plenty of storage options—HDDs, SATA SSDs, and NVMe drives. My monitor is the Samsung Odyssey G9. To be honest, I mainly run competitive and recent games on Windows, while using Linux for emulated and retro titles. My main concerns about upgrading are: getting direct storage access, the improved HDR display, avoiding crashes with DX12 games like Civilization VI, not being able to play Elden Ring properly, and the fact that some games freeze when I turn off HDR. On the other hand, I don't want to lose my current stability, enjoy smooth framerates, or get used to new settings. I'm trying to decide if a 30-day trial is enough to make the change. Any thoughts or experiences you've had would be really helpful!

S
SilverGillen
Junior Member
11
02-09-2021, 07:50 AM
#2
afaik ryzen doesn't perceive any advantage in upgrading to 11 over 10. Windows 11 isn't the massive chaos some claim it is anymore (at least not as much). Personally, I don't see a solid reason to move from 10 to 11 unless your setup is already stable. If you're on 10, keep it there; if you're on 11, consider staying put. For a fresh install, upgrading to 11 might be worth it. Edit: personally, I've used Windows 11 smoothly with only minor quirks (like a slightly larger taskbar).
S
SilverGillen
02-09-2021, 07:50 AM #2

afaik ryzen doesn't perceive any advantage in upgrading to 11 over 10. Windows 11 isn't the massive chaos some claim it is anymore (at least not as much). Personally, I don't see a solid reason to move from 10 to 11 unless your setup is already stable. If you're on 10, keep it there; if you're on 11, consider staying put. For a fresh install, upgrading to 11 might be worth it. Edit: personally, I've used Windows 11 smoothly with only minor quirks (like a slightly larger taskbar).

_
_PigMan__
Member
70
02-16-2021, 12:57 AM
#3
We receive these discussions weekly and my response remains consistent for over a year. All four of my personal systems are operating at 11 smoothly, with no issues reported. The operating system has been available in retail for 14 months now. Switching to 11 is an option, but there’s essentially no significant performance impact either way.
_
_PigMan__
02-16-2021, 12:57 AM #3

We receive these discussions weekly and my response remains consistent for over a year. All four of my personal systems are operating at 11 smoothly, with no issues reported. The operating system has been available in retail for 14 months now. Switching to 11 is an option, but there’s essentially no significant performance impact either way.

J
JR_GAMER07
Posting Freak
915
02-16-2021, 03:56 PM
#4
1. are there actually direct storage titles coming out? i mean.. i probably missed the memo if they did.. but i'd be surprised. 2. cant quote on HDR, if it's legitimately a lot better (i'd expect it to be) that might be a worthwhile consideration. 3. windows 11's release was a year ago, win10 will be supported until 2025, you're not falling behind on anything earthshattering. it's like buying a new car every year because the heads up display is 1 inch bigger than last year's model. 4. i run (ran.. i hate the game) civ6 on win10 just fine.. so i doubt that's an OS issue. 5. welcome to games made on TN panels, and run on IPS panels.. i've refunded games over this because they just didnt allow enough brightness adjustment to be usable on a display with deep blacks. and from the looks of things.. this is a very widespread annoyance with the game that i doubt is anything win11 is gonna solve for you. in my opinion, if you're running win10 now, and there is no immediate need to reinstall your computer, keep it on win10. (yes.. reinstall, i've had enough facedesk moments trying to 'upgrade' windows, where i just suggest to clean install to avoid the potential months of oddities before you realise the upgrade went wrong.) past that.. i have worked with a win11 laptop for a year, and it's grown a divine hatred for win11 inside me. i'm sure part of it is the company's piss-poor IT management (which is weird to say about an IT company..) but even the most mismanaged botched install should be able to have notepad open for more than an hour without crashing freaking notepad. i cant even start complaining about rounded corners being a waste of pixels and the MORONIC idea of center aligning the taskbar 'because apple does it', when the things i *want to do* cant even remain in working order for an entire work day. perhaps my opinion on that will change when i get around to installing it on a system of my own.. which is going to take a while because their unnecessary requirements made it incompatible with everything but my two most used devices... so i cannot test it without giving up one of the devices i need on a day-to-day basis. rant aside.. if you're fresh installing your system, and you hold no ill will against win11 so far.. you might as well go for it, and hopefully you have none of my poor experiences. and if you do.. just burn it in a fire and reinstall win10.
J
JR_GAMER07
02-16-2021, 03:56 PM #4

1. are there actually direct storage titles coming out? i mean.. i probably missed the memo if they did.. but i'd be surprised. 2. cant quote on HDR, if it's legitimately a lot better (i'd expect it to be) that might be a worthwhile consideration. 3. windows 11's release was a year ago, win10 will be supported until 2025, you're not falling behind on anything earthshattering. it's like buying a new car every year because the heads up display is 1 inch bigger than last year's model. 4. i run (ran.. i hate the game) civ6 on win10 just fine.. so i doubt that's an OS issue. 5. welcome to games made on TN panels, and run on IPS panels.. i've refunded games over this because they just didnt allow enough brightness adjustment to be usable on a display with deep blacks. and from the looks of things.. this is a very widespread annoyance with the game that i doubt is anything win11 is gonna solve for you. in my opinion, if you're running win10 now, and there is no immediate need to reinstall your computer, keep it on win10. (yes.. reinstall, i've had enough facedesk moments trying to 'upgrade' windows, where i just suggest to clean install to avoid the potential months of oddities before you realise the upgrade went wrong.) past that.. i have worked with a win11 laptop for a year, and it's grown a divine hatred for win11 inside me. i'm sure part of it is the company's piss-poor IT management (which is weird to say about an IT company..) but even the most mismanaged botched install should be able to have notepad open for more than an hour without crashing freaking notepad. i cant even start complaining about rounded corners being a waste of pixels and the MORONIC idea of center aligning the taskbar 'because apple does it', when the things i *want to do* cant even remain in working order for an entire work day. perhaps my opinion on that will change when i get around to installing it on a system of my own.. which is going to take a while because their unnecessary requirements made it incompatible with everything but my two most used devices... so i cannot test it without giving up one of the devices i need on a day-to-day basis. rant aside.. if you're fresh installing your system, and you hold no ill will against win11 so far.. you might as well go for it, and hopefully you have none of my poor experiences. and if you do.. just burn it in a fire and reinstall win10.

G
gaufran
Junior Member
18
02-19-2021, 10:15 PM
#5
This process will require an extremely long duration. Even the PS5 is limited to just one title that fully utilizes its capabilities, which was a tech demonstration. The rapid appearance of ray tracing and DLSS/FSR in games stems from their ease of integration, along with the involvement of Nvidia and AMD providing resources and expertise. Windows 11 focuses more on productivity enhancements, leaving it up to individual preference. If you rely on Windows primarily for gaming, you might overlook these changes. However, if you treat your PC as a dedicated workstation rather than just a gaming machine, Windows 11 offers significant benefits. Notepad remains stable, which is unusual for such a system. Rounded corners were appreciated in Windows 7, while Windows 8's removal was met with strong criticism due to its pixel-perfect design. The window scaling now uses square detection, and full-screen windows maintain that shape. This aligns well with ultra-wide and super-ultra-wide displays, making it intuitive for larger screens. Previously, positioning the interface on the left was logical for 4:3 or 5:4 monitors without wide screens. Ultimately, you can always adjust its placement to suit your setup.
G
gaufran
02-19-2021, 10:15 PM #5

This process will require an extremely long duration. Even the PS5 is limited to just one title that fully utilizes its capabilities, which was a tech demonstration. The rapid appearance of ray tracing and DLSS/FSR in games stems from their ease of integration, along with the involvement of Nvidia and AMD providing resources and expertise. Windows 11 focuses more on productivity enhancements, leaving it up to individual preference. If you rely on Windows primarily for gaming, you might overlook these changes. However, if you treat your PC as a dedicated workstation rather than just a gaming machine, Windows 11 offers significant benefits. Notepad remains stable, which is unusual for such a system. Rounded corners were appreciated in Windows 7, while Windows 8's removal was met with strong criticism due to its pixel-perfect design. The window scaling now uses square detection, and full-screen windows maintain that shape. This aligns well with ultra-wide and super-ultra-wide displays, making it intuitive for larger screens. Previously, positioning the interface on the left was logical for 4:3 or 5:4 monitors without wide screens. Ultimately, you can always adjust its placement to suit your setup.

F
frankyd84
Member
85
02-19-2021, 10:45 PM
#6
you might think so... after trying two laptops and several reinstalls it kept repeating. I’m sure I was dealing with an unusual situation, but I find it hard to understand what caused such problems with Notepad++, Google Chrome, OneNote, and Teams. Usually, I have three or four windows open on one screen, Win7’s rounded corners were minimal, and because of the tiling, borders overlapped so I don’t mind. But Windows 11 is trimming pixels inside rounded areas, making it look distorted. That’s the key difference—it’s a rounded edge versus cutting off space. Also, snapping works fine when the app supports it; anything fixed size can’t snap properly, so I’m used to seeing about 20 pixels of wallpaper visible. The way Windows handles snapping is much better now, which is something I’d suggest most users. Even though my 2014 Dell display came with software that handled this better than Windows 11 does, Microsoft often simplifies features to make them accessible to everyone. They’re great at adapting strong ideas from competitors but sometimes lose the finer details. It’s like the mouse snapping to the edge in Windows 8—it helps those who can’t move the mouse precisely, but it can be frustrating when you need a more accurate control. I’d love to hear your perspective on this, because differences are normal and I value varied opinions. (And please don’t let me worry about Notepad crashing while I’m using it.)
F
frankyd84
02-19-2021, 10:45 PM #6

you might think so... after trying two laptops and several reinstalls it kept repeating. I’m sure I was dealing with an unusual situation, but I find it hard to understand what caused such problems with Notepad++, Google Chrome, OneNote, and Teams. Usually, I have three or four windows open on one screen, Win7’s rounded corners were minimal, and because of the tiling, borders overlapped so I don’t mind. But Windows 11 is trimming pixels inside rounded areas, making it look distorted. That’s the key difference—it’s a rounded edge versus cutting off space. Also, snapping works fine when the app supports it; anything fixed size can’t snap properly, so I’m used to seeing about 20 pixels of wallpaper visible. The way Windows handles snapping is much better now, which is something I’d suggest most users. Even though my 2014 Dell display came with software that handled this better than Windows 11 does, Microsoft often simplifies features to make them accessible to everyone. They’re great at adapting strong ideas from competitors but sometimes lose the finer details. It’s like the mouse snapping to the edge in Windows 8—it helps those who can’t move the mouse precisely, but it can be frustrating when you need a more accurate control. I’d love to hear your perspective on this, because differences are normal and I value varied opinions. (And please don’t let me worry about Notepad crashing while I’m using it.)