F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks Compare Intel X520-SR2 and Intel X520-DA2 to see their differences.

Compare Intel X520-SR2 and Intel X520-DA2 to see their differences.

Compare Intel X520-SR2 and Intel X520-DA2 to see their differences.

Pages (2): 1 2 Next
G
Gnene
Junior Member
10
05-29-2016, 01:09 PM
#1
The main distinction lies in the SR2 models featuring optical SFP+ modules that remain fixed due to missing release latches. These can be detached with a tool like a nail. Other variations aren't mentioned in this context.
G
Gnene
05-29-2016, 01:09 PM #1

The main distinction lies in the SR2 models featuring optical SFP+ modules that remain fixed due to missing release latches. These can be detached with a tool like a nail. Other variations aren't mentioned in this context.

S
saurel31
Junior Member
39
05-29-2016, 02:44 PM
#2
The DA2 is designed specifically for TwinAx (direct attach) cabling. The SR2 includes the transceivers internally and they cannot be taken out.
S
saurel31
05-29-2016, 02:44 PM #2

The DA2 is designed specifically for TwinAx (direct attach) cabling. The SR2 includes the transceivers internally and they cannot be taken out.

R
ripa5000
Posting Freak
884
05-31-2016, 11:38 AM
#3
I found something on Reddit
R
ripa5000
05-31-2016, 11:38 AM #3

I found something on Reddit

I
iDeadlyRekt
Member
183
05-31-2016, 12:46 PM
#4
Fun fact, I used to think they were meant to be soldered, but it might have been really old.
I
iDeadlyRekt
05-31-2016, 12:46 PM #4

Fun fact, I used to think they were meant to be soldered, but it might have been really old.

L
LadyBiscoito
Member
111
06-01-2016, 01:28 PM
#5
I was nervous at first, but checking the images shows it doesn't really change much. The only difference appears to be the release latch on the SFP+ module (the part with the two Qlogic 8GB cards in my R720). If that's the main variation, it would be a solid advantage—meaning you could get SR2s instead of DA2s and receive two free optical 10GbE SFP+ modules, since DA2 and SR2 are usually priced similarly.
L
LadyBiscoito
06-01-2016, 01:28 PM #5

I was nervous at first, but checking the images shows it doesn't really change much. The only difference appears to be the release latch on the SFP+ module (the part with the two Qlogic 8GB cards in my R720). If that's the main variation, it would be a solid advantage—meaning you could get SR2s instead of DA2s and receive two free optical 10GbE SFP+ modules, since DA2 and SR2 are usually priced similarly.

_
_cryzus
Junior Member
3
06-01-2016, 08:27 PM
#6
Sure, if the prices match or are nearly identical, I’d definitely choose the SR2 since the DA2’s lower power only applies to DAC cables, which wouldn’t matter much with optics in use.
_
_cryzus
06-01-2016, 08:27 PM #6

Sure, if the prices match or are nearly identical, I’d definitely choose the SR2 since the DA2’s lower power only applies to DAC cables, which wouldn’t matter much with optics in use.

J
jrobbs7
Member
235
06-05-2016, 04:00 PM
#7
Wattage decreases in order: DAC, Optical, RJ45. I believe it’s best to avoid connecting devices electrically; optical is the only option I’m considering. DAC feels difficult to run between rooms and the expense of longer cables is much higher than fiber.
J
jrobbs7
06-05-2016, 04:00 PM #7

Wattage decreases in order: DAC, Optical, RJ45. I believe it’s best to avoid connecting devices electrically; optical is the only option I’m considering. DAC feels difficult to run between rooms and the expense of longer cables is much higher than fiber.

D
DarklyThunder
Member
241
06-05-2016, 04:47 PM
#8
DAC often causes issues most of the time, except when used in the same rack where performance is better.
D
DarklyThunder
06-05-2016, 04:47 PM #8

DAC often causes issues most of the time, except when used in the same rack where performance is better.

Z
Zaydoun
Junior Member
41
06-06-2016, 07:36 PM
#9
My AQC107 card operated at 83°C idle with significantly better heat dissipation than an SFP+ cage. Even when EEE was enabled, it only reached 77°C and remained above 80°C under load. I found the connection from my Netgear switch to the Intel card worked immediately. The driver documentation suggested whitelisting cables in the firmware, which makes sense since Linux supports that. However, I’m not certain that Fedora would override it. I prefer optical solutions because they use less space and provide electrical isolation, but these cards were more costly in AQC107 models. With only a PCIe x4 slot available on my two devices, using copper instead limits my options. Plus, I’d need another switch since all my SFP+ ports are occupied.
Z
Zaydoun
06-06-2016, 07:36 PM #9

My AQC107 card operated at 83°C idle with significantly better heat dissipation than an SFP+ cage. Even when EEE was enabled, it only reached 77°C and remained above 80°C under load. I found the connection from my Netgear switch to the Intel card worked immediately. The driver documentation suggested whitelisting cables in the firmware, which makes sense since Linux supports that. However, I’m not certain that Fedora would override it. I prefer optical solutions because they use less space and provide electrical isolation, but these cards were more costly in AQC107 models. With only a PCIe x4 slot available on my two devices, using copper instead limits my options. Plus, I’d need another switch since all my SFP+ ports are occupied.

C
ChubbsPlaysYT
Member
51
06-06-2016, 09:00 PM
#10
I currently have a Cisco SG200-26 and don’t have any SFP+ ports, but I plan to add SFP+ for my router first. Once that’s set up, I’ll move on to switching. My goal is to get 10GbE between my main PC and NAS without breaking the bank. The NIC on my main PC will need a water cooling solution since airflow is minimal unless I’m gaming.
C
ChubbsPlaysYT
06-06-2016, 09:00 PM #10

I currently have a Cisco SG200-26 and don’t have any SFP+ ports, but I plan to add SFP+ for my router first. Once that’s set up, I’ll move on to switching. My goal is to get 10GbE between my main PC and NAS without breaking the bank. The NIC on my main PC will need a water cooling solution since airflow is minimal unless I’m gaming.

Pages (2): 1 2 Next