F5F Stay Refreshed Power Users Networks 4/5G antenna recommendations

4/5G antenna recommendations

4/5G antenna recommendations

J
Josi802
Member
100
11-08-2023, 02:44 AM
#1
Using 4G offers decent performance in my area when the signal is strong and the monthly fee stays around £24. Faster connections exist via fiber, but they’re significantly more expensive—over twice the cost—and I don’t require high-speed data for games like Factorio or Rimworld. It’s something I’d consider, though it might not be worth the price. The main issue is weak signal quality: my current router shows -115dBm RSRP, -11dB RSRQ, and a 3.4dB SNR. These numbers are typical, but they’re not ideal. My setup uses the TP-Link MR600 with its included antennas. I’m thinking about swapping them, but Amazon makes it hard to judge which options are truly effective versus misleading claims. Recent reviews on Amazon seem questionable, especially with many fake ratings. The 18dB gain devices range from £6 to £86, with the more expensive ones promising omnidirectional coverage. I’d like guidance on spotting quality antennas versus generic products. Which brands are generally reliable and which are just low-cost Chinese alternatives?
J
Josi802
11-08-2023, 02:44 AM #1

Using 4G offers decent performance in my area when the signal is strong and the monthly fee stays around £24. Faster connections exist via fiber, but they’re significantly more expensive—over twice the cost—and I don’t require high-speed data for games like Factorio or Rimworld. It’s something I’d consider, though it might not be worth the price. The main issue is weak signal quality: my current router shows -115dBm RSRP, -11dB RSRQ, and a 3.4dB SNR. These numbers are typical, but they’re not ideal. My setup uses the TP-Link MR600 with its included antennas. I’m thinking about swapping them, but Amazon makes it hard to judge which options are truly effective versus misleading claims. Recent reviews on Amazon seem questionable, especially with many fake ratings. The 18dB gain devices range from £6 to £86, with the more expensive ones promising omnidirectional coverage. I’d like guidance on spotting quality antennas versus generic products. Which brands are generally reliable and which are just low-cost Chinese alternatives?

D
DocNik
Junior Member
24
11-08-2023, 01:03 PM
#2
I discovered this, and someone really messed up by trying to test the router. Also clarifies the database boost info: https://community.tp-link.com/en/home/fo...pic/272342
D
DocNik
11-08-2023, 01:03 PM #2

I discovered this, and someone really messed up by trying to test the router. Also clarifies the database boost info: https://community.tp-link.com/en/home/fo...pic/272342

B
Bidsie
Member
168
11-10-2023, 05:09 AM
#3
They need to consider the cable length. For optimal signal, use an outdoor router since it minimizes antenna cable runs—usually integrated into the PCB.
B
Bidsie
11-10-2023, 05:09 AM #3

They need to consider the cable length. For optimal signal, use an outdoor router since it minimizes antenna cable runs—usually integrated into the PCB.

J
Jordan_Gbu
Member
208
11-17-2023, 09:47 AM
#4
This information seems focused on LPDA directional antennas. I reside in an urban setting with several nearby towers. It appears directional antennas aren't always ideal here, especially with multiple sources of interference. You might consider using omnidirectional ones instead. If you're unsure, you could try pointing your current directional setup at each tower to test performance.

It's also worth noting I can move the router around as long as I have power—even a portable AC adapter works. While it probably won't be used much while traveling, the idea of an internet-connected kayak sounds fun. The ability to work remotely from unconventional spots is definitely appealing.

Setting up a small pole at the beach and mounting the antenna there could be a practical solution for working from the shore. Alternatively, bringing the equipment to relatives without internet access is another realistic option.
J
Jordan_Gbu
11-17-2023, 09:47 AM #4

This information seems focused on LPDA directional antennas. I reside in an urban setting with several nearby towers. It appears directional antennas aren't always ideal here, especially with multiple sources of interference. You might consider using omnidirectional ones instead. If you're unsure, you could try pointing your current directional setup at each tower to test performance.

It's also worth noting I can move the router around as long as I have power—even a portable AC adapter works. While it probably won't be used much while traveling, the idea of an internet-connected kayak sounds fun. The ability to work remotely from unconventional spots is definitely appealing.

Setting up a small pole at the beach and mounting the antenna there could be a practical solution for working from the shore. Alternatively, bringing the equipment to relatives without internet access is another realistic option.

B
BlitzSquadHD
Member
195
11-17-2023, 10:34 AM
#5
Typically, relying on a phone is more effective for that situation.
B
BlitzSquadHD
11-17-2023, 10:34 AM #5

Typically, relying on a phone is more effective for that situation.

A
Athame_
Senior Member
734
11-19-2023, 04:49 PM
#6
I've been researching this more and it seems directional is the superior option. I found someone on YouTube who uses the same router as me, and they recently reviewed a high-end directional antenna. It didn’t change performance, though it looks more appealing. Directional definitely outperforms omnidirectional, which makes sense when you consider the environment. It’s probably better to have a strong signal to one tower rather than a weak one across many. Placing them in an accessible spot for occasional repositioning could help, depending on the available angle. Still, it’s possible someone is using a poor omnidirectional setup—there just isn’t much data showing direct comparisons or tests.
A
Athame_
11-19-2023, 04:49 PM #6

I've been researching this more and it seems directional is the superior option. I found someone on YouTube who uses the same router as me, and they recently reviewed a high-end directional antenna. It didn’t change performance, though it looks more appealing. Directional definitely outperforms omnidirectional, which makes sense when you consider the environment. It’s probably better to have a strong signal to one tower rather than a weak one across many. Placing them in an accessible spot for occasional repositioning could help, depending on the available angle. Still, it’s possible someone is using a poor omnidirectional setup—there just isn’t much data showing direct comparisons or tests.